- Joined
- Feb 17, 2016
- Messages
- 14,844
paddysr;n3399798 said:
Pointless debating these two clowns mate.
Maxwell
Pointless debating these two clowns mate.
You cant blame Maxwell.
Its our game as as a sweeper keeper allowing us to keep pressing - decision for the pen was harsh but who'd be a ref?
in any case its not his first red
Its our game as as a sweeper keeper allowing us to keep pressing - decision for the pen was harsh but who'd be a ref?
in any case its not his first red
hatedingles;n3399808 said:
Given the first wasn't a pen and a booking not much really
- Joined
- May 22, 2016
- Messages
- 514
kbd_pne;n3399750 said:
We need a right back,left back,centre half ,keeper and targetman but as we all know that won’t happen as hemmings is to tight to spend ,yes he puts money into the club but he made it back from player sales
We are a Championship club with 2 decent keepers, but unfortunately some of our fans don’t think either of them are allowed to make mistakes and that they should keep a clean sheet every week. If either/both keepers were as good as what some fans demand, they wouldn’t be playing for us, they’d be in the Premier League. Maxwell May have cost us a couple of points today, but we’ve dropped 31 other points before today. IF Nmecha had scored near the end, Maxi wouldn’t have cost us any points. Small margins. Maxwell has let his team mates down today, along with the fans, but most of all, he’s let himself down and has now handed the jersey to Rudd.
Hypnotoad;n3399823 said:
If Maxwell isn't to blame then you must think a keeper can never be blamed/do anything wrong ever.
His performance was bordering on disgraceful. I can’t remember him having a save to make, a cross to catch or punch, and yet he managed to himself ludicrously sent off (look where those fouls were committed). We were better with 10 and a midfielder in goal!
ernest;n3399785 said:
Don't think he won a header all game, although the back four was solid as it's been in a while today. Most likely would've been a clean sheet if it wasn't for that thicko in goal.
I thought when we first signed him Maxwell was a good singing, having seen more of him I think he is impetuses and an accident waiting to happen
In his defence I have to say if he thought he was going to get the ball it was probably the right thing to ‘go for it’ being in two minds is worse, but he gives me ‘the creeps’ ever time he rushes out
Having said that Rudd would be my No1 every time, all the goals shipped under him haven’t been all his fault, after last season he would surely expect the defence in front of him to do better than they have.
For me all those goals given away were a collective thing and should have been sorted on the training ground
In his defence I have to say if he thought he was going to get the ball it was probably the right thing to ‘go for it’ being in two minds is worse, but he gives me ‘the creeps’ ever time he rushes out
Having said that Rudd would be my No1 every time, all the goals shipped under him haven’t been all his fault, after last season he would surely expect the defence in front of him to do better than they have.
For me all those goals given away were a collective thing and should have been sorted on the training ground
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2015
- Messages
- 7,872
Pissed me off so much today.
Maxwell has been playing well and it looked like we’d finally found a keeper we could rely on. Made good saves, commanded his area well in recent weeks.
Then he loses his head today after giving away the penalty, compounds it with a stupid rush of blood. How can Neil trust him after that, we are now unsettled at the goalkeeper position because he couldn’t play like a professional
Maxwell has been playing well and it looked like we’d finally found a keeper we could rely on. Made good saves, commanded his area well in recent weeks.
Then he loses his head today after giving away the penalty, compounds it with a stupid rush of blood. How can Neil trust him after that, we are now unsettled at the goalkeeper position because he couldn’t play like a professional
I haven’t seen a replay of Earls backpass to Maxi but I did witness it live and he absolutely hammered it back. Maxwell struggled to control it and then lunged to clear it at the time that he was closed down by the Ipswich forward. I thought he got the ball but I’m biased but the linesman waved his flag and gave the penalty. The 2nd foul was reckless because he knew he already had a yellow card, and he didn’t need to run over to the touch line. He went for the ball but the Ipswich sub Jackson was faster and drew a clumsy foul. Relinquishing the gloves to Rudd will point out the errors of his ways as it may be a while before we see him back in the nets. His sending off did galvanise the team and they showed a steely determination not to surrender their hard earned point. One of the best reasons for having Gally in goal over Moult was his fantastic goal kicks- he had length and accuracy!
- Joined
- Jul 21, 2010
- Messages
- 39,353
Obviously not as good as when we had Johnstone or Pickford, but a new goalkeeper wouldn't be my priority,