Skip to main content

Midfield

Midfield

We have one, at best, midfielders who can tackle which is a huge concern and problem.

We also have a midfield with little or no presence during a game. Another worry and concern.

Simply not good enough.
 
We have one, at best, midfielders who can tackle which is a huge concern and problem.

We also have a midfield with little or no presence during a game. Another worry and concern.

Simply not good enough.

I do agree, a position I think we need to strengthen either in the loan window or January, preferably January.

I would sign someone from a league 1 rival, who would you sign if you could WIBG? (Keep it realistic)
 
I do agree, a position I think we need to strengthen either in the loan window or January, preferably January.

I would sign someone from a league 1 rival, who would you sign if you could WIBG? (Keep it realistic)

I'll be honest with you mate, and this may surprise you given I'm a football expert, but I know nothing about League One so can't really offer an answer to your question.
 
This is a real problem and an interesting thread, so my thoughts are (assuming 4-3-3 and Gallagher behind the Garner) (yeah I know!!);

Kilkenny + Welsh = No! (no offence literally)
Kilkenny + Browne = Slightly Lightweight (but Browne is improving in that respect) So could be the answer.
Welsh + Browne = Yes (but need a run of games) & Welsh needs to stop sliding in all the time!!!
Welsh + Brownhill = Possibly dependent on Brownhill finding his pre season form (maybe! but some way off)
Browne + Brownhill = Very Lightweight and Brownhill more suited to replace Gallagher when he goes missing!! sorry I meant is injured!!
King + Anyone = No

Anyway just my thoughts and I understand the desire for another CM but given what we've got I know they CAN do the business.
 
This is a real problem and an interesting thread, so my thoughts are (assuming 4-3-3 and Gallagher behind the Garner) (yeah I know!!);

Kilkenny + Welsh = No! (no offence literally)
Kilkenny + Browne = Slightly Lightweight (but Browne is improving in that respect) So could be the answer.
Welsh + Browne = Yes (but need a run of games) & Welsh needs to stop sliding in all the time!!!
Welsh + Brownhill = Possibly dependent on Brownhill finding his pre season form (maybe! but some way off)
Browne + Brownhill = Very Lightweight and Brownhill more suited to replace Gallagher when he goes missing!! sorry I meant is injured!!
King + Anyone = No

Anyway just my thoughts and I understand the desire for another CM but given what we've got I know they CAN do the business.
So to sum up almost all the midfield are not good enough.
 
I'll be honest with you mate, and this may surprise you given I'm a football expert, but I know nothing about League One so can't really offer an answer to your question.

Fair point.

But if you know nothing about League One how can you compare our players to other teams in the league apart from consulting the table?

Therefore our team to you should be good enough for you at this stage of the season if we sit 2nd.
 
This is a real problem and an interesting thread, so my thoughts are (assuming 4-3-3 and Gallagher behind the Garner) (yeah I know!!);

Kilkenny + Welsh = No! (no offence literally)
Kilkenny + Browne = Slightly Lightweight (but Browne is improving in that respect) So could be the answer.
Welsh + Browne = Yes (but need a run of games) & Welsh needs to stop sliding in all the time!!!
Welsh + Brownhill = Possibly dependent on Brownhill finding his pre season form (maybe! but some way off)
Browne + Brownhill = Very Lightweight and Brownhill more suited to replace Gallagher when he goes missing!! sorry I meant is injured!!
King + Anyone = No

Anyway just my thoughts and I understand the desire for another CM but given what we've got I know they CAN do the business.

We play 3 midfielders most of the time. 4-4-2 tends not to work at home because teams pack the midfield and we get overrun.
 
Do we have a God given right to win every game now?

Decent footballers who are given time to produce and produce every time like you expect play in the Premier League and the Championship on more money, its the players we can attract unfortunately.

Ron we are in the 3rd division where teams attract players of a certain ability, some manage these types better than others (Rotherham and Brentford last season) yet last season I would not have expected either of those teams to finish above us, this season I am pleased to be where we are but concerned that against the better teams we have played so far we have struggled and been found wanting and if this season is to produce the promotion we all want we must do much better against the better teams. We managed 10 points against the teams in the top six positions last season, not good enough. If we are only seen as "flat track bullies" we will fail yet again at the play off's.
 
Ron we are in the 3rd division where teams attract players of a certain ability, some manage these types better than others (Rotherham and Brentford last season) yet last season I would not have expected either of those teams to finish above us, this season I am pleased to be where we are but concerned that against the better teams we have played so far we have struggled and been found wanting and if this season is to produce the promotion we all want we must do much better against the better teams. We managed 10 points against the teams in the top six positions last season, not good enough. If we are only seen as "flat track bullies" we will fail yet again at the play off's.

An average of 2 points per team then Billy which isn't bad for a team assembled for free and which the season prior was nearly in a relegation fight. Consider the amount of money that they all spent compared to us, Wolves had parachute payments and Brentford had narrowly missed out on automatic the season before and acquired wisely. Rotherham spent a lot of money as well and we didn't, one of the determining factors on us not going up in my opinion.

The squad and player staff were not as competitive as the top teams, on the evidence of how well Brentford and Wolves are doing in the Championship this season you can see why we couldn't knock them off there perch, but to come within 5 points is bloody good going if you ask me. Considering as well that the season before we were nearly sucked into a relegation battle, the turn around has been nothing short of immense.

We have played 2 of the better teams coming off the end of a hell of a lot of travelling an 8 winning streak and hardly any time on the training pitch because of the hectic Saturday Tuesday schedule, at the end of the day you have to realise that the players are human. How often in the past have you heard the like of Mourinho and Fergie complain about the fixture list they have been dealt, that is because it has an effect on the players more than we think.

Imagine if we had beaten Swindon and Rochdale, they probably wouldn't have been considered one of the tops teams because we would have pushed them down the table. I wonder how many on here had Rochdale to be as strong as they are proving this season, very few I reckon or did you consult your magic ball and already know this? Many had Orient to be one of the early pace setters and look at how they are doing. We can only say at the end of the season how well we have done against the top teams in the division because that is when the top 6 is decided and we have a massive effect on that. You never know Rochdale, Notts County and BC could fall away like Tranmere did, would you consider them tops teams then if we beat them but say they finish in the bottom half of the table?
 
But against other teams it doesn't.

last season we managed 10 points from 10 matches aginst those who finished in the top six, not great and so far this season (as the league stands) we have managed 0 points in 2 games against the top 6, I find this a slight worry perhaps you don't.

I would expect MK and Shef Utd to improve as the season develops and see Bristol as the team to beat, however with the squad Grayson has been allowed to assemble I would expect us to get auto but if we can't beat the better teams then we will struggle to do this.

Back to midfield, we have many who if given time to play can do just that, however against a more robust team where we need to strengthen in the middle we really only have Welsh with the others offering little or nothing in support of the defenders (as was seen at Orient where Robinson gave little or no support to an overworked Buchanan).
 
last season we managed 10 points from 10 matches aginst those who finished in the top six, not great and so far this season (as the league stands) we have managed 0 points in 2 games against the top 6, I find this a slight worry perhaps you don't.

I would expect MK and Shef Utd to improve as the season develops and see Bristol as the team to beat, however with the squad Grayson has been allowed to assemble I would expect us to get auto but if we can't beat the better teams then we will struggle to do this.

Back to midfield, we have many who if given time to play can do just that, however against a more robust team where we need to strengthen in the middle we really only have Welsh with the others offering little or nothing in support of the defenders (as was seen at Orient where Robinson gave little or no support to an overworked Buchanan).

Ive done the research for you here Billy.

Points vs Top 6 Teams Last Season

Wolves - 19
Brentford - 16
Leyton Orient - 11
PNE - 10
Rotherham - 9
Peterborough 9

FYI

Brentford lost both there top 6 games and didn't win one until the 4th game.
Wolves didn't win a top 6 fixture until there 6th fixture.
Leyton Orient won there first 3 top six games.

If we were judged on points vs Top 6 teams that would leave us 4th last season.

I agree about the midfield, but we can't fix the problem long term until January can we. Otherwise Grayson will have to make do.
 
This team is not good enough to gain automatic promotion. It's as simple as that!

Play - offs maybe.

That's the only word I'd change .. And it would be to ( barring a serious disaster) " nailed on ".


If PNE were a racehourse and Grayson was the jockey, he'd have us challenging in the pack every step of the way..... But we'd never win a race.
 
Last edited:
Ive done the research for you here Billy.

Points vs Top 6 Teams Last Season

Wolves - 19
Brentford - 16
Leyton Orient - 11
PNE - 10
Rotherham - 9
Peterborough 9

FYI

Brentford lost both there top 6 games and didn't win one until the 4th game.
Wolves didn't win a top 6 fixture until there 6th fixture.
Leyton Orient won there first 3 top six games.

If we were judged on points vs Top 6 teams that would leave us 4th last season.

I agree about the midfield, but we can't fix the problem long term until January can we. Otherwise Grayson will have to make do.

Yes, but he must have known this problem existed in midfield before we'd even kicked a ball this season and if he didn't well that's even worse.
 
Yes, but he must have known this problem existed in midfield before we'd even kicked a ball this season and if he didn't well that's even worse.

Maybe he thought the development of Brownhill and Browne would have been quicker or different? I don't know

All I know is that we do have a problem with the midfield, no point getting wound up about what he didn't do in summer as it is in the past.
 
Back
Top