Skip to main content

Mousinho

Mousinho

westley had a fresh sheet of paper to build a side and could pay higher wages than all but a few teams , he signed the best two players from tranmere , three from stevenage, yeovils captain etc etc , it wasnt hard for some one in the game to sign good players out of contract , compare this to the job that ollie did at blackpool in similar circumstances and it is apparent what a class a tool the guy was , he doesnt deserve any platitudes

So do you think Grayson would have found it easier inheriting the squad and financial situation he found himself in after Westley or if come in after Brown?
 
So do you think Grayson would have found it easier inheriting the squad and financial situation he found himself in after Westley or if come in after Brown?

All Westley did was burn money paying people off he didn't like, so that he could burn slightly smaller amounts of money on old pals like Beardsley and Mousinho, plus the sort of player that Grayson is now largely getting rid of, to be replaced with quality.

Anyone can burn money, as Westley proved. Not anyone can build a winning squad, as Westley also proved.
 
Really?

Would you swap Garner (GW signing) for Proctor?

Would you swap Keane (GW signing) for McLaughlin?

Would you swap Huntingdon (GW signing) for Devine?

Would you swop Holmes (GW signing) for Mayor?

Would you swap King (GW signing) for Miller?

These signings have us 3rd in the league, albeit under a different manager, but the ability is obviously there and was spotted by Mr Medals. Give him some credit.

I could go on but I am sure your replies will be NO to each player question that I put before you...

My sentence may not have been the best phrased but you also need to compare apples with apples. Replacing kids on peanuts with seasoned pros and then comparing their merits is like comparing apples with pears. Nobody knows how the kids would have turned out if nurtured properly.

Compare Mr Medals transfer record (including the countless failures) with Mr Grayson's - off the top of my head, I can't think of any Grayson failures.
 
I think had we not brought Grayson in this club could have been set back years by the appointment of Westley , signed maybe 6 decent players out of a scatter gun approach of 40+ in 12 months . His people skills and PR seemed to put him in a world of his own , history for me will read total fuckwit and worst manager for our club at home in living history and worst record in the clubs history at home . rose tinted glasses apart he was a twat
 
I think had we not brought Grayson in this club could have been set back years by the appointment of Westley , signed maybe 6 decent players out of a scatter gun approach of 40+ in 12 months . His people skills and PR seemed to put him in a world of his own , history for me will read total fuckwit and worst manager for our club at home in living history and worst record in the clubs history at home . rose tinted glasses apart he was a twat

Dirk says it as I see it. I can't believe people STILL think GW was ok. What the heck is that about?
 
All Westley did was burn money paying people off he didn't like, so that he could burn slightly smaller amounts of money on old pals like Beardsley and Mousinho, plus the sort of player that Grayson is now largely getting rid of, to be replaced with quality.

Anyone can burn money, as Westley proved. Not anyone can build a winning squad, as Westley also proved.

Not really answering my question
 
Dirk says it as I see it. I can't believe people STILL think GW was ok. What the heck is that about?
I do NOT think Westley was ok.

BUT, I do agree with a lot of the posters that he did a good job in getting rid of a culture of player power and disrespect that had become endemic and affect the previous manager ability to do their job.

In doing this he got rid of a set of overpaid and under-motivated players, only 1 of whom, Coutts, has gone on to play in the division that we were in.

He signed a set of non-league and lower league players on short contracts at low salaries.

The first ones of these like Procter, Holroyd, Cummins etc were brought in to change the team ethic and after having done so, soon departed.

He signed some real gems like King and Keane that no-one rated at the time as well as what have proved to be a very good core of players for the squad: Rudd, Laird, Buchanan, Holmes, Welsh, Byrom, Beavon and Garner.

A lot of clubs in our division would be (and are) pleased to have a few of the others such as Huntingdon, Robertson, Mousinho, Wroe and Monakana playing for them.

For me Westley couldn't manage, but can spot a player and see how they can fit into a team.

Next question. What did the Romans do for us?
 
Dirk says it as I see it. I can't believe people STILL think GW was ok. What the heck is that about?

I think GW was a tosser of the highest order and glad he went but SG would have had a harder job on his hands sorting both the squad and financial situation coming in after Brown than when he did.

His approach to signing players wasn't great agreed but:

Rudd
King
Huntington
Laird
Buchanan
Keane
Holmes
Beavon
Garner
Welsh
Byrom

All have or will play key parts to our promotion push and SG was able to keep Hume, sign an ex England international, a Jamaican international and loan players of Championship standard to our finances being in order.

Yes you can name alot of shit to but my point is SG had an easier job to do following Westley than he would coming in after Brown. Westley was inept in so many ways but it was an era that maybe the club needed and it was a few steps backward to leap many steps forward.

Anyway we are now SGs super white army so who gives a shit
 
The point is that SG would probably have an easier job when he started, if the job was even available, if practically anyone including the duck had come in after Brown. Whatever happens, the club was going to change after PB left given the players out of contract and need to cut the wage bill. It was an era we had to go through but it didn't need to be as crap as it was. None of SG signings break the wage structure, the Hume situation is still the same - we have him because he has a contract now as we did then.

I think GW was a tosser of the highest order and glad he went but SG would have had a harder job on his hands sorting both the squad and financial situation coming in after Brown than when he did.

His approach to signing players wasn't great agreed but:

Rudd
King
Huntington
Laird
Buchanan
Keane
Holmes
Beavon
Garner
Welsh
Byrom

All have or will play key parts to our promotion push and SG was able to keep Hume, sign an ex England international, a Jamaican international and loan players of Championship standard to our finances being in order.

Yes you can name alot of shit to but my point is SG had an easier job to do following Westley than he would coming in after Brown. Westley was inept in so many ways but it was an era that maybe the club needed and it was a few steps backward to leap many steps forward.

Anyway we are now SGs super white army so who gives a shit
 
Westley very nearly destroyed our club.

He is despised by players, managers, clubs and fans alike across the English game.

I used to cringe every time he opened his mouth, he brought shame and embarrassment on our club.

He has lost us 2000 of our attendance. He nearly killed my love for the club.

Thank the lord we have a proper, respected and well liked manager who unlike like Westley can actually get a team to win football matches.

As for comparing him to Craig Brown, absolute nonsense. Craig Brown whilst not really a success at PNE, signed some outstanding players and is one of the nicest blokes in football. Maybe too nice for his own good.

Why are we even having this debate? Westley needs to be consigned to history and back our current manager who in 12 months has made us promotion challengers.
 
The point is that SG would probably have an easier job when he started, if the job was even available, if practically anyone including the duck had come in after Brown. Whatever happens, the club was going to change after PB left given the players out of contract and need to cut the wage bill. It was an era we had to go through but it didn't need to be as crap as it was. None of SG signings break the wage structure, the Hume situation is still the same - we have him because he has a contract now as we did then.

Yes agreed and we probably did it too soon as the job was done with a short space of time. I'd rather of endured a year of shit and transition than it taken several years. Irvine, Simpson, Fergie Jnr, Brown and Westley have all been shit for this club and started a gradual decline. One bad season (horrendous season) and now I am more proud to be a PNE fan and happy to go and watch them than have been in years
 
Westley very nearly destroyed our club.

He is despised by players, managers, clubs and fans alike across the English game.

I used to cringe every time he opened his mouth, he brought shame and embarrassment on our club.

He has lost us 2000 of our attendance. He nearly killed my love for the club.

Thank the lord we have a proper, respected and well liked manager who unlike like Westley can actually get a team to win football matches.

As for comparing him to Craig Brown, absolute nonsense. Craig Brown whilst not really a success at PNE, signed some outstanding players and is one of the nicest blokes in football. Maybe too nice for his own good.

Why are we even having this debate? Westley needs to be consigned to history and back our current manager who in 12 months has made us promotion challengers.

Agree but he didn't lose us 2000 fans at all. Most clubs lose fans in their 2nd, 3rd season after relegation.

Yes SG has turned us around and only needed to sign a handful of quality players. The guy makes me proud to be a PNE fan again and just takes a back seat and doesn't get too carried away and doesn't make excuses.

The only think SG has done wrong in my eyes is publicly criticise Monakana but even that could be explained.

It's a great time to be a PNE fan.
 
The point is that SG would probably have an easier job when he started, if the job was even available, if practically anyone including the duck had come in after Brown. Whatever happens, the club was going to change after PB left given the players out of contract and need to cut the wage bill. It was an era we had to go through but it didn't need to be as crap as it was. None of SG signings break the wage structure, the Hume situation is still the same - we have him because he has a contract now as we did then.
PB left mid-season, so no players were out of contract. Even at the end of the season, it wasn't a huge proportion of the players that were.
 
The Westley attendance drop argument only goes so far nowadays. The attendance for Westley's last home game was 8300, the attendance against Colchester (9 months later) was 8400 despite Preston being top 3 and several points inside the play offs
 
Fans are easy to lose but hard to win back. After several years of decline I think under Westley we reached close to rock bottom in terms of core support for this division (which, thankfully, is about double what it was in the early 90s). I think in the second half of the season we should see things creep up again if we continue to the good work and, more importantly, give a couple of teams a good shoeing at home!
 
But the post prior to yours is also a very good point. Westley has gone so where are the fans? We are 3rd in the league
Our average attendances dropped from 11,820 in 2011/12 to just 9,214 in 2012/13. GW did a hell of a lot of damage in terms of PR for this club and fan morale in general. I'm not sure how anyone can argue otherwise. It takes time to win those fans back. After a turbulent few years I bet alot of floating fans just think this is yet another false dawn.
 
Our average attendances dropped from 11,820 in 2011/12 to just 9,214 in 2012/13. GW did a hell of a lot of damage in terms of PR for this club and fan morale in general. I'm not sure how anyone can argue otherwise. It takes time to win those fans back. After a turbulent few years I bet alot of floating fans just think this is yet another false dawn.

Most clubs lose fans in their 2nd and 3rd season after relegation though
 
Back
Top