Skip to main content

Pearson V Welsh....

Pearson V Welsh....

I'm going to have to side with The Saint here.

I find it typical of our footballing culture that John Welsh is being written off. He proved himself here a very, very long time ago and continues to do so with almost every appearance. If you're not aware of what John Welsh has brought to this side and his continued contribution then more fool you.

And to the person that wrote that he looked out of his depth at league one level, then pal, you need to completely reassess the manner in which you view the game.

Ben Pearson and the likes are being given valuable game time because they're the future of Preston North End. If we were struggling to stay a float in this division then believe me - John Welsh would be playing every week. It's his consistency, above all else, that his young protégés lack and we see that every week with either Johnson, Browne or Pearson.
 
I like Welsh, but Pearson has to start ahead of him. Welsh has done well while he's been here but with Pearson and Grimshaw yet to play. Looks like his playing time is limited. Welsh is knocking on now and that's why we've brought in these replacements.
 
John welsh is far from shite!!! Having said that the team is now moving on in many areas. His is one of them,sadly. Pearson is a cracking player and can only better.
 
Whitey tried telling you he wasn't that good at league one level and most of you lot on here did you're usual trick of shooting down anyone who's opinion differs to the one that suits your agenda. Josh Brownhill as been better for us than Pearson ever was. We got the better end of the deal easily.
 
FWIW it has to be Pearson. And that isn't doing a disservice to Welsh who I like and the fact he's still here and had 3 years under Grayson shows that he has good qualities.

But he won't be here next season, and we owe him the chance to go and play regularly somewhere and I have no doubts it will be for a decent side in league 1. He's been captain, and a leader and come on and dragged us back into games or helped us see games out. But he's 10 years older than Pearson who will be here long term, and the only way that Pearson will continue to improve is to play games.

Pearson has had spells of being really good (2nd half at Bolton and again last night) but it's no surprise he's being written off already by some because he can't shoot?? Well on last nights evidence neither can Gallagher.

The bloke behind me, I've mentioned him before because he wrote off Johnson and Beckford last season, has already made his mind up on Pearson. He doesn't like him but then he doesn't understand football, in which keeping the ball, moving into space and giving options to his team mates are key components of the game today.

Pearson will be a regular next season and will continue to improve, but he'll also have some dodgy performances on the way. Like Browne last night, who however deserves credit for not hiding and still looking for the ball even when things weren't going right for him.
 
Whitey tried telling you he wasn't that good at league one level and most of you lot on here did you're usual trick of shooting down anyone who's opinion differs to the one that suits your agenda. Josh Brownhill as been better for us than Pearson ever was. We got the better end of the deal easily.

He's right.
 
Sorry but John Welsh for me every time. Ben has the knack of looking busy, but he cant break play up, and his distribution is average at best. JW is getting a raw deal IMHO. We look very lightweight in the middle and where the fcuk was Browne all night. Now the play offs are well and truly buried, SG needs to sort the middle out. Boro away give JW a start, lets get stuck in from the start.... don't waste these last few games, lets try and dominate the key areas of the pitch.

Sorry disagree with this totally. Browne had a bad game like every player does. We dominated the game last night in midfield so don't know what game you where watching. 62% possession as well. Pearson had a really good game and offers a hell of a lot more then welsh. Welsh huffs and puffs but Pearson controlled that game. Looked for the ball and set us up with the attacks.
 
Whitey tried telling you he wasn't that good at league one level and most of you lot on here did you're usual trick of shooting down anyone who's opinion differs to the one that suits your agenda. Josh Brownhill as been better for us than Pearson ever was. We got the better end of the deal easily.

Ok, but Pearson has been better for us then Josh Brownhill ever was. There was a reason he wasn't playing.
 
Sorry disagree with this totally. Browne had a bad game like every player does. We dominated the game last night in midfield so don't know what game you where watching. 62% possession as well. Pearson had a really good game and offers a hell of a lot more then welsh. Welsh huffs and puffs but Pearson controlled that game. Looked for the ball and set us up with the attacks.

Set us up with attacks is not true at all. I can think of three times he played the ball forward and it was more towards someone than to them or at least into space and we lost the ball and that's not including the back heel to no-one! Sideways, cant fault him. Forwards, terrible.
Do Opta keep stats on PNE players?! I'd love to see them.
 
John Welsh has been a fine servant of the club and when we were seriously flirting with the prospect of relegation to the lowest division at the fag end of the GW reign he did more than any other player to help ensure that catastrophe did not happen. We owe him a huge amount. But the fact is that he has been in visible decline since the middle of last season and - odd games and flashes of his old self apart - he can no longer consistently impose himself in the way he once could. He should be released at the end of the season so he can find a regular playing position at least a division lower.
 
Pearson has offered nothing for me so far until last night. Within the first five minutes last night be made several nice need passes and held the ball up well and caught my eye straight away. A little sideways at times but kept the pace going and linked up great. Well deserved MOM and I'm sure will be an asset going forward, if you asked me that last week it would have been a different response but he made a big impression on me last night when I watched his game closely.
 
Pearson was by far and away our best player in the second half last night.

Literally the only positive in a completely inept team performance.
 
How quick we forget...JW won the 50/50 ball that got us the first goal at Wembley, he wanted it, and he won it....he's a fighter. We lack that fighter spirit in our lightweight midfield set up at this present time.. Just my opinion, but I would put him before Ben at this present time. We need to have some steel in the midfield on Sat at Boro.

Yep, I did mention he can tackle...! He just can't do anything else.
 
Pearson was by far and away our best player in the second half last night.

Literally the only positive in a completely inept team performance.

Don't go overboard will you!!

We were by far the better side for the vast majority of the game.

Fulham did a proper smash and grab.

We've done it a couple of times ourselves.

Last night was just one of those nights.

Pearson was quality last night but to all those knocking Welsh, get a grip.

He's been just as influential when he's played at this level as he was in League One.

He may not be the future but he's never let us down when he's featured.
 
Set us up with attacks is not true at all. I can think of three times he played the ball forward and it was more towards someone than to them or at least into space and we lost the ball and that's not including the back heel to no-one! Sideways, cant fault him. Forwards, terrible.
Do Opta keep stats on PNE players?! I'd love to see them.

You must have been watching a different game/player to me. Also, against Bolton he again had the ball and set us up on attacks. There was a few times last night he had the ball and spread it out wide (forward) to vermaj or Cunningham. Where you asleep last night during the match?
 
John Welsh has been a fine servant of the club and when we were seriously flirting with the prospect of relegation to the lowest division at the fag end of the GW reign he did more than any other player to help ensure that catastrophe did not happen. We owe him a huge amount. But the fact is that he has been in visible decline since the middle of last season and - odd games and flashes of his old self apart - he can no longer consistently impose himself in the way he once could. He should be released at the end of the season so he can find a regular playing position at least a division lower.

Ernest, this is the second time I've read something like this from you. I can tell that you don't actually catch many of the games. Welsh was arguably out most consistent player from middle of last season right up until his last kick of the Play-Off final. In fact his form during the back end of last season was not only a catalyst for eventual promotion but was his best period at the club.

So please stop referring to John Welsh being in decline since the middle of last season, it just points out how little you've seen and how much is pure guess work.
 
Don't go overboard will you!!

We were by far the better side for the vast majority of the game.

Fulham did a proper smash and grab.

We've done it a couple of times ourselves.

Last night was just one of those nights.

Pearson was quality last night but to all those knocking Welsh, get a grip.

He's been just as influential when he's played at this level as he was in League One.

He may not be the future but he's never let us down when he's featured.

That clearance off the line against Hull was brilliant! Saved us three badly needed points after our worst performance of the season against Huddersfield. Finally someone on the forum talks sense. Makes a change to all the negativity after one defeat. We can't win every match.
 
Don't go overboard will you!!

We were by far the better side for the vast majority of the game.

Fulham did a proper smash and grab.

We've done it a couple of times ourselves.

Last night was just one of those nights.

Pearson was quality last night but to all those knocking Welsh, get a grip.

He's been just as influential when he's played at this level as he was in League One.

He may not be the future but he's never let us down when he's featured.

Both teams were very poor, for all our possession we did absolutely nothing with it and it was a moment of individual skill from Vermijl to get us our goal.

Agree about Welsh.
 
Back
Top