Skip to main content

Pearson V Welsh....

Pearson V Welsh....

Both teams were very poor, for all our possession we did absolutely nothing with it and it was a moment of individual skill from Vermijl to get us our goal.

Agree about Welsh.

I get your point as there was little in terms of clear cut chances but we were very much on the front foot for most of the game and definitely deserved something.

I said to one of the lads that I'd never seen us start a game so brightly for a while.

Next thing, we're a goal down!
 
Set us up with attacks is not true at all. I can think of three times he played the ball forward and it was more towards someone than to them or at least into space and we lost the ball and that's not including the back heel to no-one! Sideways, cant fault him. Forwards, terrible.
Do Opta keep stats on PNE players?! I'd love to see them.

He tried a backheel when backed into a corner which very nearly came off. Drop him for good. In fact sell him.

Seems odd that people miss the point in the short passes sometimes.

Gallagher to Pearson, Gallagher moves into space, Pearson is closed down, Pearson short pass back to Gallagher who is now in space to try and create / go forward.

Don't go overboard will you!!

We were by far the better side for the vast majority of the game.

Fulham did a proper smash and grab.

We've done it a couple of times ourselves.

Last night was just one of those nights.

Pearson was quality last night but to all those knocking Welsh, get a grip.

He's been just as influential when he's played at this level as he was in League One.

He may not be the future but he's never let us down when he's featured.

^^^ pretty much how I saw/see it.

Ernest, this is the second time I've read something like this from you. I can tell that you don't actually catch many of the games. Welsh was arguably out most consistent player from middle of last season right up until his last kick of the Play-Off final. In fact his form during the back end of last season was not only a catalyst for eventual promotion but was his best period at the club.

So please stop referring to John Welsh being in decline since the middle of last season, it just points out how little you've seen and how much is pure guess work.

Yeah I've defended Welsh in a similar fashion in the past. He's been a great servant and I'm pretty sure he was a freebie, I'd be delighted for him to play vs Leeds and to get a standing ovation late in the game after he's spent 80 minutes nailing their midfield. Be a good way for him to go.
 
Ernest, this is the second time I've read something like this from you. I can tell that you don't actually catch many of the games. Welsh was arguably out most consistent player from middle of last season right up until his last kick of the Play-Off final. In fact his form during the back end of last season was not only a catalyst for eventual promotion but was his best period at the club.

So please stop referring to John Welsh being in decline since the middle of last season, it just points out how little you've seen and how much is pure guess work.

Were you at Crawley? I was and Welsh was abysmal - so much so that he was substituted for Kilkenny at half-time. Yes he had a little renaissance towards the end of last season and his tackle to set up Gallagher for the cross that led to our second goal at Wembley was superb. But the fact is that he can no longer deliver consistently - that is the key word - in the way he once could. There really is no way Welsh can now help us progress further and keeping him beyond this season would just see him decline into a sad shadow of his former self. That would no good for him or us.
 
Look guys Fulham won the physical battles all over the pitch....our midfield is very lightweight, we don't have a Gregan any more, our own version is JW, we need his presence and workrate in centre mid if we are to win these crunch games. We have lost a game tonight that has now finished off any hope of the play offs.....hindsight is a wonderful thing, but we have to think ahead to next season and a powerful centre mid is a must in this league. I would play JW on Sat along side AB and see if it gives us more control linking back to front.

Johnson, Beckford, Garner, Gallagher, Cunningham, Pickford, Johnstone, Pearson, Clarke and Browne have all come in for flack at the beginning of their tenures at Deepdale and it is simply Pearsons turn I suspect once he has got his feet under the table a bit more and starts to put in some decent performances he will be usurped by Grimshaw.

Johnson - couldn't tackle
Beckford - missing sitters
Garner - not scoring
Gallagher - shirks a tackle
Cunningham - 3rd choice LB at Bristol City
Pickford - not Johnstone
Johnstone - not Stuckmann
Pearson - not Welsh
Clarke - Huddersfield reject
Browne - has bad games

Some need to update their footballing philosophies to the 21st century and employ a degree of patience.
 
You must have been watching a different game/player to me. Also, against Bolton he again had the ball and set us up on attacks. There was a few times last night he had the ball and spread it out wide (forward) to vermaj or Cunningham. Where you asleep last night during the match?

2 things....

Who is Vermaj?
Wide is still sideways, especially to a full back.
 
Were you at Crawley? I was and Welsh was abysmal - so much so that he was substituted for Kilkenny at half-time. Yes he had a little renaissance towards the end of last season and his tackle to set up Gallagher for the cross that led to our second goal at Wembley was superb. But the fact is that he can no longer deliver consistently - that is the key word - in the way he once could. There really is no way Welsh can now help us progress further and keeping him beyond this season would just see him decline into a sad shadow of his former self. That would no good for him or us.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/30963108

Where you at Crawley!? It states here that Welsh did NOT get substituted at half time. Having said that, not one player played well at Crawley so can them players no longer deliver consistently?
 
So in your book every pass should be forward regardless of the situation ahead?

Thats far from what I said. Any of the midfielders in PNE's sqaud can pass a ball sideways to an unmarked player but when it comes to the point where it needs to be played forward or a clever pass or a difficult pass, Im afraid he just doesnt have it in his locker. Daniel Johnson does though.
 
2 things....

Who is Vermaj?
Wide is still sideways, especially to a full back.

Not if the full back is ahead of the midfield player? Because then that would be forward? Or is that too complicated for you? Sorry vermaijl! Vermaj is his cousin!
 
Not if the full back is ahead of the midfield player? Because then that would be forward? Or is that too complicated for you? Sorry vermaijl! Vermaj is his cousin!

Just a guess but...you've never played competitive football yourself?
 
Thats far from what I said. Any of the midfielders in PNE's sqaud can pass a ball sideways to an unmarked player but when it comes to the point where it needs to be played forward or a clever pass or a difficult pass, Im afraid he just doesnt have it in his locker. Daniel Johnson does though.

Really?

Check the pass he played to Cunningham for our opener against Bristol City and I know I might get slated for this but look at some of the Barnsley highlights and Man U youtube videos of him.

Have you ever thought he might be under instructions not to force the game instead he is there to create space for Gally? It's not like our forwards are regularly running in behind the opposition back line to allow him to thread the needle.

The lad is also lacking in confidence as he settles into a new division and a new team so to expect him 3 months into his Deepdale tenure to start playing a clever or difficult pass is unrealistic, I've said previously he needs to back himself more but that will come with confidence.
 
Just a guess but...you've never played competitive football yourself?

Just a guess... You was asleep last night and you didn't go on the Bolton game. Pearson set us up on plenty of attacks in that match too. And Daniel Johnson has played poorly for months so at the moment deserves to be sat on the bench.
 
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/30963108

Where you at Crawley!? It states here that Welsh did NOT get substituted at half time. Having said that, not one player played well at Crawley so can them players no longer deliver consistently?

Yes I was and Welsh was replaced by Kilkenny for the second half. Just to repeat Welsh has been a great servant of the club but there simply comes a time when retaining a player will do no-one any good and tarnish the previous memories of how they played. Welsh is now at that point. So may well be Clarke and Huntington. So, though his service has not been at the same level, may be Kilkenny. So may Humphrey.
 
Yes I was and Welsh was replaced by Kilkenny for the second half. Just to repeat Welsh has been a great servant of the club but there simply comes a time when retaining a player will do no-one any good and tarnish the previous memories of how they played. Welsh is now at that point. So may well be Clarke and Huntington. So, though his service has not been at the same level, may be Kilkenny. So may Humphrey.

But it states in the match report here and on sky sports that Welsh was not replaced at all. What game where you watching. I like Welsh and yes it is probably time for him to look for a new club, but don't tarnish all the good things Welsh has done by one match over a year ago in which the whole team did not play well. He has also done well this season against Middlesborough and Hull - two sides challenging for promotion.
 
But it states in the match report here and on sky sports that Welsh was not replaced at all. What game where you watching.
ernest is right - Welsh was replaced by Kilkenny for the second half. That match report is incorrect.

So I have to ask, what game were you watching? I'm guessing you weren't watching the Crawley game at all.
 
He has also done well this season against Middlesborough and Hull - two sides challenging for promotion.

He was also hooked just after half time against Rotherham at home, a team fighting relegation. Only when he was replaced for Browne did we show any attacking threat.

We got the better end of the deal easily.

You don't own either player....they are both ours. How is that a "better deal" for you ?
 
Just a guess... You was asleep last night and you didn't go on the Bolton game. Pearson set us up on plenty of attacks in that match too. And Daniel Johnson has played poorly for months so at the moment deserves to be sat on the bench.

You're incorrect.

I agree Daniel Johnson is not playing well at the minute but he has so much more to offer than Pearson going forward.
 
Quite simply if we want to progress as a club we need to look further than John Welsh , been a good servant but at best a squad player and think he may need to drop down a division to get regular football.
No complaints from me with his contribution but we need to up the anti to progress.
 
He was also hooked just after half time against Rotherham at home, a team fighting relegation. Only when he was replaced for Browne did we show any attacking threat.

Was this the game that Johnson started on the bench as well? Can't remember what game it was when Welsh came on which seemed a odd sub at the time but he allowed pretty much both full backs and the other midfielders to bomb on and it changed the game.

Points relating to stuff you haven't quoted...

There's very few saying Welsh should be in, and basically he shouldn't. We're not scrapping around for points or trying to make games ugly, we're looking to build a squad that will improve next season and this really is the main reason why Pearson should be in over Welsh right now.

Using the Crawley thing to beat him up over is out of order as well really, everyone was shocking in that game and didn't we then go on a 25 game unbeaten run or something which he was a part of? Good servant, but coming to the end of his time now, to say that time was 6-9 months ago is completely incorrect.
 
Back
Top