Skip to main content

Poor Joe

Poor Joe

He gives 100% every game

But sadly his 100% at this level is just not good enough to be more than a squad player but not a starter
 
You have to remember that the last time we had strikers good enough to fire us to the top six at championship level were a young David nugent and a fit Ricardo fuller. Before that you have to go as far back as Alex Bruce. Is garner as good as a fit Ricardo fuller or a young David nugent? Is he heck as like. But that's the standard we will need to find. It won't be easy.
 
You have to remember that the last time we had strikers good enough to fire us to the top six at championship level were a young David nugent and a fit Ricardo fuller. Before that you have to go as far back as Alex Bruce. Is garner as good as a fit Ricardo fuller or a young David nugent? Is he heck as like. But that's the standard we will need to find. It won't be easy.

We need 4 good strikers.

I'd be happy enough with Garner and Becks being two of them next season.
 
I just hope the Burnley CH checked his back pocket before he left last night, because if he didn't, he's in for a big surprise this morning when he finds Joey, there!

I feel sorry for Joey as he's not had much support this season, so it may be too soon to write him off at this level, but the signs don't look good.
 
Amazing

Started a thread around Christmas time , and asked the question is garner good enough? IMO it was obvious half a season ago that he wasn't . And I got slated for it.


Now it seems everyone has changed their tune.

He gives 100% but he isn't championship quality , it's as simple as that .

Hope the guys who own PNE Online have some medals to send out.
 
Judge Garner after part of a season playing with a good strike partner in a team playing with confidence in their ability at Championship level.

Garner has still chipped in with goals and a few assists and for the first half of the season we were a nervous, bottom half of the league side who were playing with little or no confidence therefore Grayson decided to go defensive to get some points on the board, hard to score in a side that were playing defensive to get the confidence levels up.

You can't expect him to come up a division and carry on scoring the way he was when playing up top on his own in a team new to the division.

Lets see what he's like after we have a summer of recruitment, Gallagher without his injury, Beckford without his injury and a team not afraid of the division from the off.
 
He's done alright for his first season back.

Never had any real quality up there with him this season and it's been hard work for him.

I'd rather have him in the side than the likes of Johnson and Robinson who just don't look arsed to me at all.
 
He gives 100% every game

But sadly his 100% at this level is just not good enough to be more than a squad player but not a starter

I didn't quite see 100% last night. There were many challenges where he wasn't committing for the ball - gave the defence an easy time. More like just trying to put off the defender by being in the vicinity or playing the man. Plus quite a bit of strolling. Hardly Vardyesque. Thought he should have been subbed earlier for Hugill.
 
Watford and forest let him go at this level, shame it seems to be coming apparent why. Bit like he has forgot what he did well last year, letting shots go quickly, sharp shooting from outside the box, seems to have lost that confidence.

Can't fault his effort.
 
You have to remember that the last time we had strikers good enough to fire us to the top six at championship level were a young David nugent and a fit Ricardo fuller. Before that you have to go as far back as Alex Bruce. Is garner as good as a fit Ricardo fuller or a young David nugent? Is he heck as like. But that's the standard we will need to find. It won't be easy.

I like Garner but he's not even a Richard Cresswell who scored goals as well as having a great work rate. That said I still think with a consistent decent partner (Beckford) & decent service he will come good.
 
I didn't quite see 100% last night. There were many challenges where he wasn't committing for the ball - gave the defence an easy time. More like just trying to put off the defender by being in the vicinity or playing the man. Plus quite a bit of strolling. Hardly Vardyesque. Thought he should have been subbed earlier for Hugill.

Can't agree with that. Whatever you might say about him he always puts a shift in & at least looks like he gives a toss unlike some.
 
Thought they did look like they gave a toss last night, just beaten by the quality that premiership parachute payments can afford.

I think out of the clubs that will come down villa might struggle to stay in the championship

But any combination of Norwich, Newcastle and Sunderland will both probably bounce straight back up again so looking at competing for play offs next year.

More goals needed if we are to do so.
 
I didn't quite see 100% last night. There were many challenges where he wasn't committing for the ball - gave the defence an easy time. More like just trying to put off the defender by being in the vicinity or playing the man. Plus quite a bit of strolling. Hardly Vardyesque. Thought he should have been subbed earlier for Hugill.

Thats what happens when he gets a card early on.
 
Thats what happens when he gets a card early on.

Which is why the opposition do anything they can to get him booked. They know if they cause an incident like Lowton did then the ref will automatically book both players, regardless of who was at fault.
 
Which is why the opposition do anything they can to get him booked. They know if they cause an incident like Lowton did then the ref will automatically book both players, regardless of who was at fault.

Joe has created this controversy, if you look at the lowton incident (I assume you're talking about when they both got booked) Joe started it by leaning into the lad first. He is now a parody of himself to be honest, controversy follows him thus when he does legitimately get snapped he doesn't get the decision. His time is up at North end I honestly believe it, he is holding us back. Love what he's done for us but time to go - hope you prove me wrong, if you get the chance.
 
I think out of the clubs that will come down villa might struggle to stay in the championship

But any combination of Norwich, Newcastle and Sunderland will both probably bounce straight back up again so looking at competing for play offs next year.
QUOTE]

Agree about Villa though I suspect Newcastle might well have difficulties adjusting to life a division lower. Norwich are used to bouncing up and down between the top two divisions and will almost certainly be a force if they come down. Sunderland are hard to call - if they do come down will Big Sam stay or will he get pushed? More pertinently what will Pickford's situation be?
 
Garner needs to score goals in order to score more. Confidence player. Nowt wrong with that when things are going well, things just haven't clicked this season.

Bet you he has a break this summer and comes back twice as good.
 
Garner needs to score goals in order to score more. Confidence player. Nowt wrong with that when things are going well, things just haven't clicked this season.

Bet you he has a break this summer and comes back twice as good.

That's a long time to be depressed.
 
Back
Top