Skip to main content

Safe Standing

Safe Standing

Joined
Feb 14, 2015
Messages
105
Location
Preston
With the likes of Bristol City and Cardiff both piloting the movement and introducing safe-standing sections into their stadiums, do you think we will see safe-standing areas at Deepdale in the near future?

Recent polls have unveiled a resounding amount of support towards safe-standing, so it's clear that the majority of fans advocate the idea.

I've recently posted an article on my blog (link below) regarding safe-standing, so feel free to check out my personal opinion.

https://bobmelling.wordpress.com/
 
Nice blog.

I'm all for standing at games, and safe standing. However, the murals of Finney, Shankley, and Kelly are for me one of the things which make Deepdale unique and I wouldn't want that gone.

Maybe the Invincibles pavillion could be used to trial it at first?
 
Nice blog.

I'm all for standing at games, and safe standing. However, the murals of Finney, Shankley, and Kelly are for me one of the things which make Deepdale unique and I wouldn't want that gone.

Maybe the Invincibles pavillion could be used to trial it at first?

Thanks!

I agree; the murals are a unique part of the aforementioned stands. Perhaps it could be trialled in the Invincibles to begin with. I just think it would really enhance the atmosphere at trialledund and give those fans who wish to stand the option to do so.
 
Last edited:
I'm all for safe standing as a concept, but in relation to PNE, I can't see us spending money on this, whilst the murals in the seats, as sedgwick__7 said, is what helps make Deepdale unique.
 
Football has changed
The days of the terrace and rose tinted image of the stereotypical fan are a thing of the past
Today a family of grandad, mum and child are much more of the demographic- would they want to stand?
The concept of a particular area segregated for standing could work but then you could be accused of denying the sitters the opportunity to view the game from that particular area and of course the converse view for the standers?
 
I'm all for safe standing as a concept, but in relation to PNE, I can't see us spending money on this, whilst the murals in the seats, as sedgwick__7 said, is what helps make Deepdale unique.

It's a great concept, but it's all about whether Trevor would be willing to pilot the scheme. The capital expenditure to adapt the stand would be an issue, but I think we could definitely make it work.
 
The whole notion of a 'pilot' scheme to see if standing up is safe is really quite amusing.

Presumably they will erect that silly standing seat gear at crazy expense and after a period of time 'assess' the outcome which will be that there were no issues. How can this be predicted you ask?

Because each and every week since 'all seat' stadia were invented, a great many thousands of fans stand in front of their seats without incident.

Why are there no incidents? It's because the terraced stands on which the seats are bolted are not overcrowded and the presence of the seats prevents groups gathering in packs and pushing forward 'Kop style' whenever there is anything to get excited about on the pitch (the modern style of professional football tends to prevent the excitement bit tbh)

So there you go. Findings sorted. So why will it take massive amounts of cash for the suits to work it out?
 
I disagree with using part of the Invincibles stand as a standing area. It's a relatively new stand so there is no point in removing seats from it and I don't think it's the best place to house standing fans anyway.

What about the half of the Finney stand that doesn't have Tom's mural on. That's usually the empty part of the stadium so a standing area there could fill that space.
 
The whole notion of a 'pilot' scheme to see if standing up is safe is really quite amusing.

Presumably they will erect that silly standing seat gear at crazy expense and after a period of time 'assess' the outcome which will be that there were no issues. How can this be predicted you ask?

Because each and every week since 'all seat' stadia were invented, a great many thousands of fans stand in front of their seats without incident.

Why are there no incidents? It's because the terraced stands on which the seats are bolted are not overcrowded and the presence of the seats prevents groups gathering in packs and pushing forward 'Kop style' whenever there is anything to get excited about on the pitch (the modern style of professional football tends to prevent the excitement bit tbh)

So there you go. Findings sorted. So why will it take massive amounts of cash for the suits to work it out?

Well , there was a broken leg sustained at MK when our lot were standing in the seats .
 
Football has changed
The days of the terrace and rose tinted image of the stereotypical fan are a thing of the past
Today a family of grandad, mum and child are much more of the demographic- would they want to stand?
The concept of a particular area segregated for standing could work but then you could be accused of denying the sitters the opportunity to view the game from that particular area and of course the converse view for the standers?

All very true. The demographic of football fan attending the games has dramatically changed since the terraces went. Football in general is becoming more of a family orientated event, but I still think we should have safe-standing sections for those who want the option to stand. It's a tricky predicament regarding fans being denied the right to view the game from a particular section of the ground and an issue that would have to be analysed in a lot of depth.
 
The whole notion of a 'pilot' scheme to see if standing up is safe is really quite amusing.

Presumably they will erect that silly standing seat gear at crazy expense and after a period of time 'assess' the outcome which will be that there were no issues. How can this be predicted you ask?

Because each and every week since 'all seat' stadia were invented, a great many thousands of fans stand in front of their seats without incident.

Why are there no incidents? It's because the terraced stands on which the seats are bolted are not overcrowded and the presence of the seats prevents groups gathering in packs and pushing forward 'Kop style' whenever there is anything to get excited about on the pitch (the modern style of professional football tends to prevent the excitement bit tbh)

So there you go. Findings sorted. So why will it take massive amounts of cash for the suits to work it out?

I accept your point, but as I mention in my blog; at the majority of away games we constantly see people complaining about someone standing up in front of them. With safe-standing sections these archetypal issues would be avoided. Fans who wish to sit do not have to worry about their view being obstructed by the people in front of them who want to stand up. You simply buy a ticket in a standing section or you buy a ticket in an all-seater section.

The same applies at Deepdale. It's all about giving people the option to stand, as it's already been proven that the majority of us prefer standing. Where you place the standing sections is a different matter.
 
I accept your point, but as I mention in my blog; at the majority of away games we constantly see people complaining about someone standing up in front of them. With safe-standing sections these archetypal issues would be avoided. Fans who wish to sit do not have to worry about their view being obstructed by the people in front of them who want to stand up. You simply buy a ticket in a standing section or you buy a ticket in an all-seater section.

The same applies at Deepdale. It's all about giving people the option to stand, as it's already been proven that the majority of us prefer standing. Where you place the standing sections is a different matter.

A Choice........ End of argument for me.
 
I disagree with using part of the Invincibles stand as a standing area. It's a relatively new stand so there is no point in removing seats from it and I don't think it's the best place to house standing fans anyway.

What about the half of the Finney stand that doesn't have Tom's mural on. That's usually the empty part of the stadium so a standing area there could fill that space.

The part of the Finney which is normally fairly empty would be a good place to erect a standing area. We would encounter the least amount of issues, as only a small number of fans would be affected.
 
The part of the Finney which is normally fairly empty would be a good place to erect a standing area. We would encounter the least amount of issues, as only a small number of fans would be affected.


It needs to be behind one of the goals mate...Right in the middle.... Honestly. anywhere else would result in what happened with our " singing section".... Shoved up into a corner on the extreme wing of a stand was never going to have the desired effect.
 
Thanks!

I agree; the murals are a unique part of the aforementioned stands. Perhaps it could be trailed in the Invincibles to begin with. I just think it would really enhance the atmosphere at the ground and give those fans who wish to stand the option to do so.

Can't see the Invincibles being used as the hospitality sector is a big growth area for the club.
 
If PNE can't afford to sort out the 2000 "damaged" seats around the ground, then there is no way that they'll fork out thousands to rip out good undamaged seats.

I am all for standing, be it Safe Standing or as we currently do high up on The Town End.
 
If PNE can't afford to sort out the 2000 "damaged" seats around the ground, then there is no way that they'll fork out thousands to rip out good undamaged seats.

I am all for standing, be it Safe Standing or as we currently do high up on The Town End.

The undamaged seats could replace the damaged ones...... Speculate to accumulate.
 
I'm all for standing at games, and safe standing. However, the murals of Finney, Shankley, and Kelly are for me one of the things which make Deepdale unique and I wouldn't want that gone.
I've been lucky enough to have been flown over Deepdale in a small private plane on a Wednesday afternoon in summer - probably at around 2,500ft. The seat murals are indeed unique and look inspirational from on high, and another thing about PNE which sets us apart. I'm all in favour of 'safe' standing, but suggest other clubs have a go first and see what lessons we can learn before taking it on board ourselves.
 
Back
Top