Skip to main content

Safe Standing

Safe Standing

Poll Poll Safe Standing

  • Yes

    Votes: 103 78.0%
  • No

    Votes: 22 16.7%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 7 5.3%

  • Total voters
    132
On the fsf website. You can see on most of the pictures of rail seats there is room for 2 rows of people. The face there's only 2 rows is what makes it safe i.e. No chance of a crush.

If everyone just stands in front of the seat how come the capacity and attendances rise when it's used? There was talk of reducing ticket prices due to being able to get more in.

It seems that we are both correct.

http://www.fsf.org.uk/campaigns/safe-standing/safe-standing-facts/

Rail seats incorporate a safety barrier and a flip-down seat on every other row (or step). These seats can be locked in an upright position for domestic games, allowing two rows of supporters to stand in between barriers. Supporters can thus be given a designated ‘seat’ (or standing plot) but watch the game while standing. With only two rows of fan per barrier there is no danger of a crush or progressive crowd collapse, and this technology facilitates the inclusion of up to 80% more supporters than a seated area of similar size.
 
Aye, I guess the having a designated standing spot could take away the standing with mates unless you buy a ticket together (like now), though I guess if the standing section is big enough it won't be a problem to just move.

I've been to quite a few stadiums in Germany and whether in safe standing terracing or normal terracing, I've never been allocated a standing spot as all terracing tickets are unreserved. I think it would be the same in England should 'safe standing' be introduced, which in my opinion it definitely should!
 
I don't know how old you are mate - but I remember the bad old days when I stood up, in dangerous conditions, struggling to actually see the game. True, the atmosphere was better, but I wouldn't sacrifice safety for atmosphere. I know they assure us they would make it safe, but this month of all months, do we believe them?

We're not talking about the terraces of old though - this is safe standing with rail seating (one person per seat). I suggest doing a bit more research into it so you know what it's all about.

Can't understand why people are against it - is it wrong to give people the option of standing?
 
I've been to quite a few stadiums in Germany and whether in safe standing terracing or normal terracing, I've never been allocated a standing spot as all terracing tickets are unreserved. I think it would be the same in England should 'safe standing' be introduced, which in my opinion it definitely should!

Germany uses terraces still in most places. In england you would be given a seat number still as the entire nature of safe standing is that the seat is still there it is just locked up
 
With all seated stadium based on the Taylor report which came out of all the lies around the Hillsborough disaster surely that report has no substance anymore!?!?
 
I don't know how old you are mate - but I remember the bad old days when I stood up, in dangerous conditions, struggling to actually see the game. True, the atmosphere was better, but I wouldn't sacrifice safety for atmosphere. I know they assure us they would make it safe, but this month of all months, do we believe them?

Bad old days your having a laugh aren't you ? .... best days of watching football in my lifetime them.

Get standing back !!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Just a thought
Has PNE ever done a marketing survey based on an average matchday crowd - It feels to me that this is a real 50-50 split on sit or stand?


That's a figure relating to who wants to sit or who wants to stand and I wouldn't argue with it although the days of terracing would very much disagree with you................ The real question however is how many think there should be a choice.... I'll match and counter your own " guess " and say 90% are in favour of freedom of choice.
 
That's a figure relating to who wants to sit or who wants to stand and I wouldn't argue with it although the days of terracing would very much disagree with you................ The real question however is how many think there should be a choice.... I'll match and counter your own " guess " and say 90% are in favour of freedom of choice.

I guess I would agree
Ps
You can sit or stand in corporate. In fact you can employ the use of a chaise longue
 
It is deemed perfectly safe - and is often the only choice - to stand up on the London Underground and rail network trains, travelling at speeds of up to 100mph (forced). The same for urban public buses. It is also deemed safe for spectators of football to stand up and watch at all grounds other than top leagues grounds, where it is deemed unsafe.
Secondly, there was very nearly a deadly crush at Hillsborough in the 1981 FA Cup semi-final, and virtually nothing was done to prevent a repeat incident.
Gross incompetence, and a subsequent attempt to cover up this incompetence, caused far too many people into what amounted to a cattle pen that day.
The Taylor Report should be immediately torn up, and a fresh enquiry, and a completely new set of recommendations ought to be performed.

Control numbers going into a ground, and the removal of the cages, and the chance of a Hillsborough style crush will reduce to that of any other spectator event involving standing spectators.

There is a problem with the steepness and height of each step on the Town End, such that its a fair "jump" down to the next step, unlike the pleasantly shallow terracing it replaced.
For this reason, barriers may be necessary to prevent people falling forward. But, at Bolton a couple of years ago, in the very steeply angled seats (gradient, as well as price), a gentleman did end up falling about 6 rows forward as result of losing his balance.

The All seater stadium - post Taylor report - revolution, was the biggest money making scam in football history, as ticket prices hiked up many times above the price of inflation "for the luxury of providing you with a seat" that many fans no longer actually use. The only reason this debate never gets past the debate stage is because the clubs face the prospect of losing money-per-fan as a result. So they'll continue to play the "we-don't-want-another-tragedy card" because that far better suits their agenda.
Standing up is quite obviously a safe way to spectate anything, unless you have slipped a disc in your lumbar spine, in which case it is agony.
 
Last edited:
Yes. But I stand safely already at all the matches I attend. Can't remember the last time I actually sat through a match
 
Yes and a thousands time yes. I'd even considering banging a drum again if it was brought back in 😛

I can't believe 22 people have voted 'no'!

Actually seeing some of the replies from people who clearly don't know what rail seating is or think the whole ground will be transformed I can believe it.
 
Back
Top