Skip to main content

Sam Johnstone

Sam Johnstone

I don't think he's "all that" to be honest, certainly not to the extent people have been raving about him on here.

I don't recall him keeping us in games with a string of wonder saves, and in most games he has had precious little to do.

If we'd have borrowed him from Huddersfield or somewhere, and word hadn't got out about the supposed £1m price tag, I reckon most would be calling him bang average.

People see what they want to see and factors such as playing for Manchester United and potential £1 million pound transfer fees, possibly subconciously, clouds peoples judgments.

I've no problem with the lad and he probably edges Stuckmann overall, but if we were to actually get promoted I think we could get a 'keeper of equal ability at a fraction of the outrageously inflated transfer fee being spoken of, or even another decent loan from a top club, costing us peanuts.

£1 million pounds would likely be a huge chunk of of our transfer budget, and I reckon it could be spent elsewhere on quality outfield players. Particularly when you consider Daniel Johnson cost us a mere £50K.

This lad could well turn out to be amazing, who knows, very early days, but I've yet to witness anything from him that would me convince to spend £1m quid on the boy.

Tin hat at the ready.

From what I've seen I think his kicking is questionable, but he commands his box very well and looks to be a good shot stopper. Agree £1m seems a lot of money but he's had sod all to do in most games so we haven't seen his true ability yet, and that's down to our excellent defence.
 
Um he's better than Stuckmann but not quite as good as Rudd. His kicking reminds me of the keeper we had under Beck (was it Barry Richardson,) and need improvement.
 
I bet your glad though you got back onside with Grayson though after this last 12 games and ready for the run in .

Ive always been on Graysons side, to the point that I was called a WUM for it but quite a few of those posters now have egg on their face.

But hey Dirk I will let you have your fun of trying to wind people up on an online forum because you have nothing better to do with your life.
 
I don't think he's "all that" to be honest, certainly not to the extent people have been raving about him on here.

I don't recall him keeping us in games with a string of wonder saves, and in most games he has had precious little to do.

If we'd have borrowed him from Huddersfield or somewhere, and word hadn't got out about the supposed £1m price tag, I reckon most would be calling him bang average.

People see what they want to see and factors such as playing for Manchester United and potential £1 million pound transfer fees, possibly subconciously, clouds peoples judgments.

I've no problem with the lad and he probably edges Stuckmann overall, but if we were to actually get promoted I think we could get a 'keeper of equal ability at a fraction of the outrageously inflated transfer fee being spoken of, or even another decent loan from a top club, costing us peanuts.

£1 million pounds would likely be a huge chunk of of our transfer budget, and I reckon it could be spent elsewhere on quality outfield players. Particularly when you consider Daniel Johnson cost us a mere £50K.

This lad could well turn out to be amazing, who knows, very early days, but I've yet to witness anything from him that would me convince to spend £1m quid on the boy.

Tin hat at the ready.

I tend to agree Neal, but for every little thing he does perfect the Stuckmann agenda's will be being warmed up.
 
From what I've seen I think his kicking is questionable, but he commands his box very well and looks to be a good shot stopper. Agree £1m seems a lot of money but he's had sod all to do in most games so we haven't seen his true ability yet, and that's down to our excellent defence.

As I've stated previously I rate him but £1 million does seem excessive, maybe there is a bit of negotiating to be done come the summer.
 
Ive always been on Graysons side, to the point that I was called a WUM for it but quite a few of those posters now have egg on their face.

But hey Dirk I will let you have your fun of trying to wind people up on an online forum because you have nothing better to do with your life.



As oooo pointed out Ron you said time for a change in January , but its ok i let you off enjoy your evening
 
Decent keeper. Quick off his line. Decent presence, Brave in a crowd. Kicking is a bit suspect, but not terrible. Wouldn't say he makes many extraordinary saves. He's decent, but he doesn't stand out to me as exceptional.
However, steady and predictable is good enough for most clubs.
 
Don't really get this keeper is better than that keeper crap ....
The goals against column in most divisions means that at some point a keeper will be exposed hence the goals against column.
The difference between teams than win promotions and those that don't is the defence working as a unit and protecting the keeper who should be the last line of defence.
Keepers like Banks, Clemence, Shilton, Seaman, and the foreign keepers like Schmicheal all had pretty good defenders in front of them.
For me our modern day example was Tepi who had a solid defence in front of him but had his limitations.
Jones had a decent record at orient but it never worked out here but Johnstone has done well with the same defence so maybe he is the missing piece of the jigsaw.
 
As oooo pointed out Ron you said time for a change in January , but its ok i let you off enjoy your evening

And as I've said I don't recall saying that and I looked through by post history and it didn't seem to be there.

For the 1000 posts i put up supporting Grayson its hilarious how the 1 maybe doubting him is used to satisfy an agenda and argument.
 
Decent keeper. Quick off his line. Decent presence, Brave in a crowd. Kicking is a bit suspect, but not terrible. Wouldn't say he makes many extraordinary saves. He's decent, but he doesn't stand out to me as exceptional.
However, steady and predictable is good enough for most clubs.

I'd take that from a keeper at the age of 21! And I really rate him, miles better than Stuckers (although I have no issue with him at all). Think we've been blessed with 3 decent keepers over the time that we've been in this shocking division. However, £1m? Not too sure.
 
I'd take that from a keeper at the age of 21! And I really rate him, miles better than Stuckers (although I have no issue with him at all). Think we've been blessed with 3 decent keepers over the time that we've been in this shocking division. However, £1m? Not too sure.

Not too sure why the 1m rumour has been accepted as fact. However, he is super confident for a 21 year old, and he isn't the type of keeper that makes you anxious (apart from slightly wayward kicking).

Rudd is being treated as a super hero but he had his faults, and I remember being a little anxious at times watching him. Maybe this guy is the real deal.
 
I see people have started slagging Rudd now, who was the greatest thing since sliced bread last season.

He was a very decent keeper, and for me I need to see a lot more from SJ to convince me he is a better goalie than Rudd.

Early days for Johnstone, and he could prove an excellent acquisition, but way too premature to judge one way or another.
 
I see people have started slagging Rudd now, who was the greatest thing since sliced bread last season.

He was a very decent keeper, and for me I need to see a lot more from SJ to convince me he is a better goalie than Rudd.
Early days for Johnstone, and he could prove an excellent acquisition, but way too premature to judge one way or another.

I agree ... only problem maybe can we afford to blow the rumoured £1m on Sam ?.
Rudd was decent but would we spend £1m on him if available ?
Big call if we go up....
 
I agree ... only problem maybe can we afford to blow the rumoured £1m on Sam ?.
Rudd was decent but would we spend £1m on him if available ?
Big call if we go up....

As I said previously, I think we could get a very able keeper on loan from a top club and the money could be better spent elsewhere on quality outfield players, unless TH is about to go on a mad shopping spree which I cannot foresee.
 
I see people have started slagging Rudd now, who was the greatest thing since sliced bread last season.

He was a very decent keeper, and for me I need to see a lot more from SJ to convince me he is a better goalie than Rudd.

Early days for Johnstone, and he could prove an excellent acquisition, but way too premature to judge one way or another.

I like both Rudd and Johnstone.

Rudd was brilliant for us last season, but I feel some are too quick to compare SJ to him. SJ is 2/3 years younger and like you say, it's still early days for him. We've had him for 3 months and we had Rudd for about 18 months.

Let's see what the summer brings anyway.
 
Not too sure why the 1m rumour has been accepted as fact. However, he is super confident for a 21 year old, and he isn't the type of keeper that makes you anxious (apart from slightly wayward kicking).

Rudd is being treated as a super hero but he had his faults, and I remember being a little anxious at times watching him. Maybe this guy is the real deal.

All fair points. I for one, can't really see these £1m runours as being true.
 
I agree ... only problem maybe can we afford to blow the rumoured £1m on Sam ?.
Rudd was decent but would we spend £1m on him if available ?
Big call if we go up....

Surely some of the £1m, which was a figure quoted by Dickov who was annoyed that Johnstone was recalled, will be paid in instalments based on appearances etc
 
Back
Top