Skip to main content

Scott Laird

Scott Laird

Laird is a brilliant left-back and OK as a left-sided 'wing-half'. He is very poor as the wide left midfielder in a 4.4.2 formation. But oddly I have a sneak feeling he might be quite good as a more central midfielder.

Not agile enough for a centre mid Ernest.

He’s a bit of a one trick pony, in the sense that his effectiveness depends entirely on being able to bulldoze through his opponent. He managed it on 2 or 3 occasions in the second half at County, in contrast with the second half at Posh when he got no change out of his man at all.

Having an offensive threat in that area of the park is a huge plus for us though (shades of Grezza) and his height at the back is also handy (a la Rob Edwards).
 
Great player but I thought yesterdays 'assist' was possibly one of his poorer shots?

We always hear the 'experts' talking about shooting across goal for the very reason that Laird did. Back of the net.

Excellent player, one of our best and certainly needs tying down with a longer contract.
 
Not agile enough for a centre mid Ernest.

He’s a bit of a one trick pony, in the sense that his effectiveness depends entirely on being able to bulldoze through his opponent. He managed it on 2 or 3 occasions in the second half at County, in contrast with the second half at Posh when he got no change out of his man at all.

Having an offensive threat in that area of the park is a huge plus for us though (shades of Grezza) and his height at the back is also handy (a la Rob Edwards).

Fair enough - as I've said before Laird is very good player though he does not possess either great pace or significant trickery. What he does have is strength, the ability to strike a ball well - whether crossing or shooting - and a knack of getting into crucial positions at the right time. This is why he was so effective as an attacking fullback - because he could get up from deep to arrive unmarked in the penalty area - and so poor as a conventional wide left midfielder - because that just turned into a rather lumbering 'winger' who could be easily marked out of the game. This odd hybrid 'wing-half' role is not ideal for him - I would still like us to revert to a four-at-the-back formation - but rather perversely sounding it is enough of a defensive role for him to remain an attacking threat.
 
At the end of the day Scott Laird as more than enough in his locker to make him a stand out player at this level no matter what position we play him. Had a chat with the guy prior to the mk dons away game last season and he said he actually started his career as a center back playing the sweeper role. For me when he as to defend he's up their with the best of them but he loves being "on the ball". He also said two championship clubs wanted him I think one was Millwall but he wanted to follow his manager across so I suppose lol that's one good thing Westley did for us because for me the guy is priceless for us.
 
At the end of the day Scott Laird as more than enough in his locker to make him a stand out player at this level no matter what position we play him. Had a chat with the guy prior to the mk dons away game last season and he said he actually started his career as a center back playing the sweeper role. For me when he as to defend he's up their with the best of them but he loves being "on the ball". He also said two championship clubs wanted him I think one was Millwall but he wanted to follow his manager across so I suppose lol that's one good thing Westley did for us because for me the guy is priceless for us.

He is a good player for us at this level but priceless he is not.
 
I though he was over hyped last season when he was out injured. Westley was always using his injury as an excuse and one of the reasons that we were not doing well. I was wrong, on this form, we really did miss him last year, although why Westley didn't use the excellent Buchanan is a mystery. He has got his fitness back 100%, and is still running hard after 90 minutes. I like the way he cuts inside onto his right which always seems to wrong foot opponents. I think playing wing back is his perfect position as he is partially covered by Bailey Wright on the left at the back 3. He's got a bit of everything; good tackles, great crosses,passes, and a threat with his head from deadball situations and balls in from the right. Buchanan is a better defender and Hayhurst is probably a better winger but Scott is the complete left sided wing back.
 
I think he is priceless mate cause every goal he scores every assit helps us on our journey back to the championship and to be back in the championship with all the extra revenue that will generate is priceless the or us. And to find another Scott Laird were you would even begin to look and at what price. Trust me mate over the course of the season the guy will be priceless for us
 
I agree surf and IF we had 11 Scott Laird's in the team, promotion would be a formality. We really do need to get back into the Championship ASAP. Yesterday really highlighted that fact for me, as there was a lot of excitement/interest to see who we had drawn in the first round of the FA Cup. If we were in the Championship, I doubt most of us would have realised the cupp draw was being made.
 
I think he is priceless mate cause every goal he scores every assit helps us on our journey back to the championship and to be back in the championship with all the extra revenue that will generate is priceless the or us. And to find another Scott Laird were you would even begin to look and at what price. Trust me mate over the course of the season the guy will be priceless for us

I agree totally about the need to get out of this division. What you say about goals and assists is true for every player.As I said, I think Laird is a good player just that priceless is a little ott. I think we are lucky to have both him and DB, I don't think he would be sitting on the bench for many teams in this league.
 
I agree surf and IF we had 11 Scott Laird's in the team, promotion would be a formality. We really do need to get back into the Championship ASAP. Yesterday really highlighted that fact for me, as there was a lot of excitement/interest to see who we had drawn in the first round of the FA Cup. If we were in the Championship, I doubt most of us would have realised the cupp draw was being made.

Is he a good keeper too ? ��
 
Is just different class.... Of all our players he's the one in my opinion that could walk into any championship team and not look out of place. Our last three goals have been from three assits by Scott!. Some people say he cant do this or he cant do that but lets focus on what he can do. On the ball his awareness of what's around him means he sees things early which offensively or defensively is of tremendous benefit to the team, his deadball deliveries are something else, he drives us forward from deep dragging the opposition players out of position and he can score goals.

Like he said himself just the other day he's back to his best and the stats and his performances are showing just that.

I think Laird is a useful player but think we might be going a bit over the top here Steve.

Strengths
Delivery
Vision

Weaknesses
Lack of pace
In a One v one there are many better fullbacks in this division

A useful player to have in your squad but it is a good job he gets so many assists because his defending is average at best.
 
I think he is priceless mate cause every goal he scores every assit helps us on our journey back to the championship and to be back in the championship with all the extra revenue that will generate is priceless the or us. And to find another Scott Laird were you would even begin to look and at what price. Trust me mate over the course of the season the guy will be priceless for us

Nail on head, Surf - SL has something about him - and he's ours!!
 
In my opinion I think that he's one of the best left backs we've had in a while

Agreed Keith.

It wasn't that long ago we didn't even have a recognised left back, we now have I believe a very good one (Laird) and a decent one at this level (Buchannan).
 
I think he is priceless mate cause every goal he scores every assit helps us on our journey back to the championship and to be back in the championship with all the extra revenue that will generate is priceless the or us. And to find another Scott Laird were you would even begin to look and at what price. Trust me mate over the course of the season the guy will be priceless for us

Who'd of thought it more assists since Laird came back in to the team. Quality player
 
Please don't think for a minute that his shot at Notts County was anything other than a piss poor shot, label it as an assist if you have the rose tints on.

Laird is a decent player but lacks real pace to play this wingback position, get back to a 442 where is can do a real job and overlap his winger and we will see much more from him imho.
 
Please don't think for a minute that his shot at Notts County was anything other than a piss poor shot, label it as an assist if you have the rose tints on.

Laird is a decent player but lacks real pace to play this wingback position, get back to a 442 where is can do a real job and overlap his winger and we will see much more from him imho.

Agree on the 442. If we scored from it then its an assist. Buchanan for example may not have got in to that position and that's why Laird is a good asset but his lack of pace means he is limited. Although Humphrey has it to burn and doesn't offer any more
 
Back
Top