Will our ex chairman be in attendance this evening...what sort of reception will he get..........and now time has moved on how do we realistically assess the Shaw Years ?
Shaw Thing
Will our ex chairman be in attendance this evening...what sort of reception will he get..........and now time has moved on how do we realistically assess the Shaw Years ?a
Being realistic he was Chairman from 2001 - 2010 which included the most successful Preston North End have been since 1964.
Degsy - once a Townie always a Townie.
Indifferent for me JR , not bad start but the fallout with Billy, who I thought he was jealous of and didn't handle very well when we were one of the best sides in the Championship, was the top of the ladder and we very soon jumped onto the snake to find us where we are today
Put him the stocks at half time and throw cabbages/rotten eggs at him.
- Joined
- Mar 31, 2005
- Messages
- 8,487
Shaw negotiated more than his fair share of good transfer deals and compensation deals in his time.
He did indeed. Darren Carter being an excellent example.
WDD
It had to be a team effort
It had to be a team effort
Is there or was there a 'Shaw Thing'? Clearly during his time 'in charge', he authorised spending of way more than we were bringing in. But a higher authority (obviously Mr Hemmings) must also have provided the cash and hence also authorised the spending.
Bottom line, had we made it to the prem, Derek Shaw would probably have the same hero status as the likes of William Suddell, Jimmy Milne, David Moyes, and to some, Billy Davies.
The fact is that we didn't, and the rest is history.
Anyone remember the posts on here accusing the club and Shaw/Hemmings of "lacking ambition"? Then when he started to spend more than we could afford, it all went pear shaped, and DS was demoted to village idiot status.
We had some really good years under Derek, but we are certainly paying for it now.
It had to be a team effort
Is there or was there a 'Shaw Thing'? Clearly during his time 'in charge', he authorised spending of way more than we were bringing in. But a higher authority (obviously Mr Hemmings) must also have provided the cash and hence also authorised the spending.
Bottom line, had we made it to the prem, Derek Shaw would probably have the same hero status as the likes of William Suddell, Jimmy Milne, David Moyes, and to some, Billy Davies.
The fact is that we didn't, and the rest is history.
Anyone remember the posts on here accusing the club and Shaw/Hemmings of "lacking ambition"? Then when he started to spend more than we could afford, it all went pear shaped, and DS was demoted to village idiot status.
We had some really good years under Derek, but we are certainly paying for it now.
Is there or was there a 'Shaw Thing'? Clearly during his time 'in charge', he authorised spending of way more than we were bringing in. But a higher authority (obviously Mr Hemmings) must also have provided the cash and hence also authorised the spending.
Bottom line, had we made it to the prem, Derek Shaw would probably have the same hero status as the likes of William Suddell, Jimmy Milne, David Moyes, and to some, Billy Davies.
The fact is that we didn't, and the rest is history.
Anyone remember the posts on here accusing the club and Shaw/Hemmings of "lacking ambition"? Then when he started to spend more than we could afford, it all went pear shaped, and DS was demoted to village idiot status.
We had some really good years under Derek, but we are certainly paying for it now.
So did he renting out assets to the club as Friends of PNE.
Probably made a lot more from PNE than he did from Shelving.
Will our ex chairman be in attendance this evening...what sort of reception will he get..........and now time has moved on how do we realistically assess the Shaw Years ?
I think we should! Water under the bridge for me.
He did indeed. Darren Carter being an excellent example.
WDD
Not really. That was the manager's choice. Shaw merely made the money available to fund the deals. It wasn't his fault the players were sometimes stale dog piss.
I'm talking the good sums for transfers out, the compo figures for managers, and the ground redevelopment.
- Joined
- Mar 31, 2005
- Messages
- 8,487
Not really. That was the manager's choice. Shaw merely made the money available to fund the deals. It wasn't his fault the players were sometimes stale dog piss.
I'm talking the good sums for transfers out, the compo figures for managers, and the ground redevelopment.
I'm not talking about the quality of the players, more the long term contracts on sky high wages that he dished out like confetti.
As it happens, he oversaw the most successful era in the last half century, but we are still paying the price now. Ambition versus reality. Shit or bust. Was it worth it? IF we had made it to the promised land you would have to say yes. But we didn't, so I'd say not.
WDD
84% of clubs were overspending at the time, some sources say up to 88%. To get in Prem stars like Carter we had to pay him what he asked for. I blame Thatcher and the 'I want it nowwwww' attitude of people of this godforsaken century.
I'm not talking about the quality of the players, more the long term contracts on sky high wages that he dished out like confetti.
As it happens, he oversaw the most successful era in the last half century, but we are still paying the price now. Ambition versus reality. Shit or bust. Was it worth it? IF we had made it to the promised land you would have to say yes. But we didn't, so I'd say not.
WDD
He got some good deals for an aging Lucketti, or McKenna, and an outstanding deal for Nuge too. Plus some good compo for the managers that got poached. He had a knack of buying low and selling high. That is until he came unstuck due to the signing of shit players. He always tried to make money available for new signings, before caving into the pressure and spending beyond his means in a vain attempt to appease the fans, and keep up the desire to challenge at the top end of the Championship.
I like to think this is a fair assessment.
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2004
- Messages
- 4,922
He was sat there last night in the Directors Box, Finney Stand. Open necked shirt, no club tie and mouthing the words along with the rest of the plastics 'Prestons a ******** I wanna go home'
WDD
WDD
Bardas
Putin – khuylo
- Joined
- Aug 16, 2004
- Messages
- 11,715
Shaw`s major mistake...imo..was gambling with Hemming`s money a little at a time, season after season, for the best part of a decade.
There was a brief moment under Billy when perhaps he could/should have given the team a financial stimulus that may just have got us to the Prem..then the moment passed.
His major contribution was to oversee the completion of the ground, and the negative side of his slow gamble...ie, we spent a decade in the Championship, which however you look at it, was our best showing for decades in terms of league position.
There was a brief moment under Billy when perhaps he could/should have given the team a financial stimulus that may just have got us to the Prem..then the moment passed.
His major contribution was to oversee the completion of the ground, and the negative side of his slow gamble...ie, we spent a decade in the Championship, which however you look at it, was our best showing for decades in terms of league position.
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2004
- Messages
- 10,645
Derek did some good stuff (e.g. finishing off the ground) and some bad stuff. Ultimately though, for me, what he achieved on the pitch (in effect, nothing) and what it cost (an awful lot) make his chairmanship a general failure.
Did he leave the club in a good state to progress? No, definitely not.
Did he leave the club in a good state to progress? No, definitely not.
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2004
- Messages
- 3,052
And IF we had beaten Bolton or WestHam he'd have gone down as our greatest chairman ever i guess!
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2008
- Messages
- 457
Without doubt we had our greatest spell of football for decades whilst under Chairmanship of Degsy, We was all happy for the contracts to be given out in order to get these players at the time, looking back now its cost us and a main factor to where we are now.
I do feel that he backed the wrong managers at the wrong time, Didnt really back Billy enough to give us that push over the line.
Gave Simpson some money at the start and whilst up there in Jan, failed to back him with some quality to keep us at the top instead we got Ricketts, Pergyl and Soley.
Then backed Irvine to keep us up, and after doing so we seem to spend a lot on transfer fee's and Wages.
I do feel that he backed the wrong managers at the wrong time, Didnt really back Billy enough to give us that push over the line.
Gave Simpson some money at the start and whilst up there in Jan, failed to back him with some quality to keep us at the top instead we got Ricketts, Pergyl and Soley.
Then backed Irvine to keep us up, and after doing so we seem to spend a lot on transfer fee's and Wages.
dirk pnemouse
The Gentry (RIP)
- Joined
- Nov 1, 2006
- Messages
- 26,968
Had the St ledger transfer gone through he may well still be running this club now , he did some very good things in his time as chairman for me his biggest mistake was Alan Irvine and the dismantling of the wage structure = boom and bust approach and were still paying for that now .
Shaw`s major mistake...imo..was gambling with Hemming`s money a little at a time, season after season, for the best part of a decade.
There was a brief moment under Billy when perhaps he could/should have given the team a financial stimulus that may just have got us to the Prem..then the moment passed.
His major contribution was to oversee the completion of the ground, and the negative side of his slow gamble...ie, we spent a decade in the Championship, which however you look at it, was our best showing for decades in terms of league position.
I don't get this as Trev's finance man John Kay knew exactly where the money was going and would supply Trev with all the details.