Skip to main content

Should we drop Stuckmann?

Should we drop Stuckmann?

Even though your whole act is a piss take, your not doing very well at the moment, shame on you.

Why?

You think it's good man management to firstly not give a player a chance when their direct rival for the shirt is making mistake after mistake? And then when you do finally give him a chance you then go and bring in someone else and replace him when he's done very little wrong.

I'm not sayng Stuckmann is a better keeper, but it's all about managing players and getting the best out of them.
 
Whatever he's decided, in terms of man management, I'm sure SG has sat Stuckmann down and explained his decision to him man-to-man.

And I'm sure Stuckmann in turn will have taken it in his stride like a proper professional, not flounced out in disgust like a slapped arse.
 
Terrible man management if Grayson drops him for the game on Friday.

May as well give Stuckman a free transfer if Grayson drops him.

He is 33 and out of contract at the end of the season, it would be good player and financial management if Stuckmann was to leave as there are better and cheaper 2nd strong goalies out there. I love Stuckers but there is no sentiment in football.

You play your best players, Johnstone seems the better of the two.

Why?

You think it's good man management to firstly not give a player a chance when their direct rival for the shirt is making mistake after mistake? And then when you do finally give him a chance you then go and bring in someone else and replace him when he's done very little wrong.

I'm not sayng Stuckmann is a better keeper, but it's all about managing players and getting the best out of them.

I don't think Johnstone was brought in to replace Stuckmann because Stuckmann has made the odd gaffe, Johnstone became available and he is one for the future.

You don't stand still in football you constantly improve and as a club building towards Championship football Johnstone was a good acquisition and is one for the future, whilst Stuckmann is at the tail end of his career.

Your anti-grayson agenda is boarding on obsessive.
 
Why?

You think it's good man management to firstly not give a player a chance when their direct rival for the shirt is making mistake after mistake? And then when you do finally give him a chance you then go and bring in someone else and replace him when he's done very little wrong.

I'm not sayng Stuckmann is a better keeper, but it's all about managing players and getting the best out of them.

Stuckmann could possibly be going back to Germany in the Summer as he's out of contract. Got to look long term.

If Man United signed Hummels, should Van Gaal carry on playing likes of Smalling or Blackett instead of him?
 
Why?

You think it's good man management to firstly not give a player a chance when their direct rival for the shirt is making mistake after mistake? And then when you do finally give him a chance you then go and bring in someone else and replace him when he's done very little wrong.

I'm not sayng Stuckmann is a better keeper, but it's all about managing players and getting the best out of them.

Spot on about giving Stuckmann a chance. I asked when Jones made mis judgement after mis judgement what was the point of giving Stuckmann another contract when Grayson clearly had little faith in him. He only got a chance when there was basically no choice because Jones was starting to look like a startled rabbit. Not good man management on the face of it, maybe didn't do Jones any favours either by leaving him in.
 
It is no coincidence that a deal was reached with Man U on Sunday after Stuckmann had played badly on Saturday for the second game running. It wasn't a case of Johnstone just becoming available. He had been available since the beginning of January.

Johnstone has to start the league games. He hasn't given up the number 1 spot at Doncaster to be number 2 here.

I doubt whether Stuckmann will be offered a new contract for next season.
 
Last edited:
It is no coincidence that SG approached Man U on Sunday after Stuckmann had played badly on Saturday for the second game running.

Johnstone has to start the league games. He hasn't given up the number 1 spot at Doncaster to be number 2 here.

I doubt whether Stuckmann will be offered a new contract for next season.

Deal was agreed last Thursday. Johnstone didn't want deal to go through until after Saturday as he didn't want to leave Doncaster short for their league game.
 
Deal was agreed last Thursday. Johnstone didn't want deal to go through until after Saturday as he didn't want to leave Doncaster short for their league game.

I've no idea how you would know this, but if so then it only reinforces the notion that SG and GS were feeling uneasy about the qualities of the goalkeepers. They had already, earlier, lost confidence in JJ, despite giving him several opportunities to redeem himself. After the Walsall game, maybe circumstances allowed them to pre-empt further problems by getting in Johnstone early in case Stuckmann, whom I admire on many levels, made any more errors of judgement. After the SU game SG could be feeling justified.
 
I admire Stuckmann greatly for doing a generally good job since he joined in circumstances that were often very difficult. And all the while has been nothing but a consumate professional.

It seem very likely that Johnstone will now be first choice, and I don't think anyone could realistically quibble with that but I very much hope that Stuckmann gets his richly deserved day in the sun before the season is out.

And to WIBG. I found it utterly laughable that you question the man management skills of Grayson. The man isn't beyond reproach but as players have come and gone under his regime the constant has always been a happy and united squad.
 
Johnstone won't have come here to warm the bench, he's an England international from a big club, plus was getting first team football at Doncaster. It would appear jones is on his way out, makes no sense to have 3 keepers. Stuckman will go back to being a cup keeper and he seems to appreciate the fact that north end have given him a chance. It will be interesting however to see who starts Friday as stuckman can't be blamed for the poor defending that lead (in my eyes) to both goals against Sheffield United.
 
Stuckman has cost us goals in the last 2 games, seems harsh but if you were going to drop him now is the time.
I know this might be regarded as a lame excuse, but do you not think that the weather might have played a part in his error against Walsall.
It's also very interesting how people focus on his errors. Only 2 have been cited. Might be good to think about some of his saves; Barnsley?
 
First goal against walsall a free kick, watch it back and you'll see the wall was non existent and gave stuckman no protection. The second was a cock up from wiseman and fair enough may be shouldn't have come charging out so quickly, but again his defence left him exposed. Sheff U, first goal-poor defending again that looped over him and he had no chance. Second goal we backed off and backed off until ryce was that close any player should have scored. Our defence is too powder puff, either put your body on the line or get a challenge in sooner.
 
First goal against walsall a free kick, watch it back and you'll see the wall was non existent and gave stuckman no protection. The second was a cock up from wiseman and fair enough may be shouldn't have come charging out so quickly, but again his defence left him exposed. Sheff U, first goal-poor defending again that looped over him and he had no chance. Second goal we backed off and backed off until ryce was that close any player should have scored. Our defence is too powder puff, either put your body on the line or get a challenge in sooner.

I'm a fan of Stuckman, but...1st goal bs Walsall was due to a freekick given away after sloppy play by him, the wall was poor but it was the keepers side to protect and vs Sheff Utd the 2nd should have been saved, e won't be happy about that one!
 
The second goal was drilled low and hard, right between his legs. Harsh to blame him considering the defending from the outfield players involved.

Exactly! Let's face it, shit happens. If Buchs had got a block in, if Stucks had set up better, if your aunt had nuts.......
 
Funny thing is the free kick was nothing special, wasn't particularly high or hit at pace. Had the wall done it's job, it'd of hit it, I think Beckford was the one on the edge of the wall being distracted by one of their players. Either way stuckman saw it at last minute and couldn't react. The fact is the defence needs to wake up because until walsall, it was well disciplined and conceded very little. Confidence is lacking, that's obvious to see
 
Stucks has been a great servant for pne yet we talk about dropping him like its nothing , i think he deserves a bit more respect than that , be a shame if he left and our shining new star got a knock . to play the waiting game he has with such a professional attitude he deserves a medal but I'm sure he would settle for a little respect and a thank you .
 
Back
Top