Skip to main content

Should we drop Stuckmann?

Should we drop Stuckmann?

Stucks has been a great servant for pne yet we talk about dropping him like its nothing , i think he deserves a bit more respect than that , be a shame if he left and our shining new star got a knock . to play the waiting game he has with such a professional attitude he deserves a medal but I'm sure he would settle for a little respect and a thank you .

I totally agree Dirk, but I have a gut feeling that the club are treating him the 'right' way and do have a lot of respect for his contributions and efforts over the last three years. I'm sure the club are encouraging and supporting the advancement of his career after his North End playing days are over. He's certainly not a used Kleenex!
 
I know this might be regarded as a lame excuse, but do you not think that the weather might have played a part in his error against Walsall.
It's also very interesting how people focus on his errors. Only 2 have been cited. Might be good to think about some of his saves; Barnsley?

I personally wouldnt drop him and yes weather can't have helped vs walsall. I've been very impressed with him over the past 2 months or so and think he's earnt the shirt for the time being. That said before then I don't think I would have given him that chance.
 
I believe Grayson has never had much faith in stuckman, we seem to get another keeper who always has preference over him .
 
I think it's a disgrace how Stuckmann's being treated. What exactly did he do wrong against Walsall except one dodgy clearance on a slippy pitch? He was the messiah the week before.
 
I think it's a disgrace how Stuckmann's being treated. What exactly did he do wrong against Walsall except one dodgy clearance on a slippy pitch? He was the messiah the week before.


Ive a feeling he will be missed greatly one day even by those who dismiss him so easily , ive heard the saying no room for sentiment in football many times but never so dismissively when they player is still at the club .
 
I'm a big fan of Stuckers - liked him since day one. But..............

I don't remember this uproar when Jones came in and stole his place.
 
I'm a big fan of Stuckers - liked him since day one. But..............

I don't remember this uproar when Jones came in and stole his place.


I don't think 1 or 2 people asking for a bit of respect is uproar , still if you begrudge him that then ok
 
For what it's worth, I preferred Stucks over Jones the whole time. Miles more of a presence, and miles more commanding.

I can't see Johnstone not starting on Fri night, so will see what I think of him from the Town End on the night.
 
I'm a big fan of Stuckers - liked him since day one. But..............

I don't remember this uproar when Jones came in and stole his place.
+1

As a minimum, Stuckmann still has the JPT tie to come, and still an outside chance of a Wembley appearance, plus a winnable FA Cup tie to come, and if we do win that, who knows who else he'll get to face?

Plus we can be pretty confident Stuckmann and Grayson will have discussed all this between themselves with all due respect given on both sides and nobody throwing a tantrum or anything.

I like Stuckmann a lot - and I particularly thought the way he was treated by Westley when Simonsen was manoeuvred into the first team was a disgrace.

But I think we can be sure he isn't being treated that way this time, and if he starts on the bench this Friday, I don't think we need to worry unduly for his morale or well-being.
 
For what it's worth, I preferred Stucks over Jones the whole time. Miles more of a presence, and miles more commanding.

I can't see Johnstone not starting on Fri night, so will see what I think of him from the Town End on the night.


I'm all for giving the lad a chance mate if he's the better choice its just those coming out with crap like no room for sentiment or trying to make out hes crap thats annoying me , i think he deserves better than that
 
I'm all for giving the lad a chance mate if he's the better choice its just those coming out with crap like no room for sentiment or trying to make out hes crap thats annoying me , i think he deserves better than that

Agreed. I must admit, if he does get pushed onto the bench, I reckon I'll actually miss the big guy. He's done us proud over the last few years.
 
I suspect that Jones will leave on loan once we are out of the cup competitions, assuming that someone will want to take him off us.

Maybe an emergency loan deal until the end of the season to another League 1 club?
 
Back
Top