- Joined
- May 30, 2014
- Messages
- 4,821
I thought perhaps a debate on Simon Grayson was necessary.
To proceed I would like to make it clear I do believe he has been our steadiest appointment since Billy Davies. I like many others was delighted when he got the nod and at the time thought only Owen Coyle (may) have been better.
Since then although I see positives in his managerial style I also see negatives in him.
Firstly I do like his general demeanor and the way he presents himself overall. OK he's not what one would call a personality but we have had style over substance before and it doesn't wash with fans unless you're winning week in week out. I was disappointed with his comments after the play off games and would have preferred him to say we had been thoroughly outplayed rather than glossing it up. Overall it's good not to have a total lunatic in charge.
Secondly SG does inspire confidence in his past achievements and his history of taking clubs out of league 1.
Third he has contacts in the game and a network. It could be debated he seems to rely on players that have performed well for him at his previous clubs. As Clarke has proved this can be a plus but I wonder how inspired this is when ultimately you start guessing what ex Huddersfield player is next on the list.
His teams are set up not to lose rather than win. I really despise this tactic. It produces dull and ultimately negative football. I want to be entertained at games please Simon. I do know people like to win, I do but I hardly remember winning games with panache last Season.
I like the way we get good press now but I feel that Radio Lancs and the E post tend to lose their critical faculties when interviewing him and act like friends rather than impartial sports journalists (has SG done a fans forum yet).
He must go one better and deliver promotion next season. I think possibly only Alan Irvine has been backed as well in recent years by Hemmings.
My overall view on his tenure so far is about 6/10.
To proceed I would like to make it clear I do believe he has been our steadiest appointment since Billy Davies. I like many others was delighted when he got the nod and at the time thought only Owen Coyle (may) have been better.
Since then although I see positives in his managerial style I also see negatives in him.
Firstly I do like his general demeanor and the way he presents himself overall. OK he's not what one would call a personality but we have had style over substance before and it doesn't wash with fans unless you're winning week in week out. I was disappointed with his comments after the play off games and would have preferred him to say we had been thoroughly outplayed rather than glossing it up. Overall it's good not to have a total lunatic in charge.
Secondly SG does inspire confidence in his past achievements and his history of taking clubs out of league 1.
Third he has contacts in the game and a network. It could be debated he seems to rely on players that have performed well for him at his previous clubs. As Clarke has proved this can be a plus but I wonder how inspired this is when ultimately you start guessing what ex Huddersfield player is next on the list.
His teams are set up not to lose rather than win. I really despise this tactic. It produces dull and ultimately negative football. I want to be entertained at games please Simon. I do know people like to win, I do but I hardly remember winning games with panache last Season.
I like the way we get good press now but I feel that Radio Lancs and the E post tend to lose their critical faculties when interviewing him and act like friends rather than impartial sports journalists (has SG done a fans forum yet).
He must go one better and deliver promotion next season. I think possibly only Alan Irvine has been backed as well in recent years by Hemmings.
My overall view on his tenure so far is about 6/10.