Skip to main content

Simon Grayson Analysis

Simon Grayson Analysis

Joined
May 30, 2014
Messages
4,821
I thought perhaps a debate on Simon Grayson was necessary.
To proceed I would like to make it clear I do believe he has been our steadiest appointment since Billy Davies. I like many others was delighted when he got the nod and at the time thought only Owen Coyle (may) have been better.
Since then although I see positives in his managerial style I also see negatives in him.
Firstly I do like his general demeanor and the way he presents himself overall. OK he's not what one would call a personality but we have had style over substance before and it doesn't wash with fans unless you're winning week in week out. I was disappointed with his comments after the play off games and would have preferred him to say we had been thoroughly outplayed rather than glossing it up. Overall it's good not to have a total lunatic in charge.
Secondly SG does inspire confidence in his past achievements and his history of taking clubs out of league 1.
Third he has contacts in the game and a network. It could be debated he seems to rely on players that have performed well for him at his previous clubs. As Clarke has proved this can be a plus but I wonder how inspired this is when ultimately you start guessing what ex Huddersfield player is next on the list.
His teams are set up not to lose rather than win. I really despise this tactic. It produces dull and ultimately negative football. I want to be entertained at games please Simon. I do know people like to win, I do but I hardly remember winning games with panache last Season.
I like the way we get good press now but I feel that Radio Lancs and the E post tend to lose their critical faculties when interviewing him and act like friends rather than impartial sports journalists (has SG done a fans forum yet).
He must go one better and deliver promotion next season. I think possibly only Alan Irvine has been backed as well in recent years by Hemmings.
My overall view on his tenure so far is about 6/10.
 
I thought perhaps a debate on Simon Grayson was necessary.
To proceed I would like to make it clear I do believe he has been our steadiest appointment since Billy Davies. I like many others was delighted when he got the nod and at the time thought only Owen Coyle (may) have been better.
Since then although I see positives in his managerial style I also see negatives in him.
Firstly I do like his general demeanor and the way he presents himself overall. OK he's not what one would call a personality but we have had style over substance before and it doesn't wash with fans unless you're winning week in week out. I was disappointed with his comments after the play off games and would have preferred him to say we had been thoroughly outplayed rather than glossing it up. Overall it's good not to have a total lunatic in charge.
Secondly SG does inspire confidence in his past achievements and his history of taking clubs out of league 1.
Third he has contacts in the game and a network. It could be debated he seems to rely on players that have performed well for him at his previous clubs. As Clarke has proved this can be a plus but I wonder how inspired this is when ultimately you start guessing what ex Huddersfield player is next on the list.
His teams are set up not to lose rather than win. I really despise this tactic. It produces dull and ultimately negative football. I want to be entertained at games please Simon. I do know people like to win, I do but I hardly remember winning games with panache last Season.
I like the way we get good press now but I feel that Radio Lancs and the E post tend to lose their critical faculties when interviewing him and act like friends rather than impartial sports journalists (has SG done a fans forum yet).
He must go one better and deliver promotion next season. I think possibly only Alan Irvine has been backed as well in recent years by Hemmings.
My overall view on his tenure so far is about 6/10.

He sets his team up to get the best out of the players at his disposal. If we're honest the best we thought would happen last season was play offs and that's what we got. Deep down I think we all expect automatic promotion next season and I trust SG to go and get the players to do that. Snodin says we are after pace and that is clearly what we need. If he gets these players, expect us to play a more open style next season. He's a horses for courses manager and I have great faith in him.
 
He sets his team up to get the best out of the players at his disposal. If we're honest the best we thought would happen last season was play offs and that's what we got. Deep down I think we all expect automatic promotion next season and I trust SG to go and get the players to do that. Snodin says we are after pace and that is clearly what we need. If he gets these players, expect us to play a more open style next season. He's a horses for courses manager and I have great faith in him.

I agree completely. Grayson is the ultimate pragmatist, if you don't have the flair in the squad, playing expansive, entertaining football will lead to failure.
 
He sets his team up to get the best out of the players at his disposal. If we're honest the best we thought would happen last season was play offs and that's what we got. Deep down I think we all expect automatic promotion next season and I trust SG to go and get the players to do that. Snodin says we are after pace and that is clearly what we need. If he gets these players, expect us to play a more open style next season. He's a horses for courses manager and I have great faith in him.

It's interesting that you say he's a horses for courses manager. Did you not think considering he had the likes of Gallagher and a strong backbone that the team played within themselves last season?
 
It's interesting that you say he's a horses for courses manager. Did you not think considering he had the likes of Gallagher and a strong backbone that the team played within themselves last season?

Not really. I felt they were about the 5th best team in the division. We had no pace out wide and no-one other than Garner who was quality up front. That does not lend itself to an attack minded team. Rome wasn't built in a day and this transfer window is the next phase in a development plan which started from a Chris Beardsley/ John Mousinho horror level. The first phase was to stop losing every bloody game and that was achieved in some style.
 
Good balanced OP but I would give him 8/10 overall. He's subtely changed a squad with limited funds and yes we don't get beat a lot. We've had some great always this year. The home form by the end of the season was good. Next year is the time to judge as he can hopefully start the season with the likes of Gally, Garner, kila and some new faces. One criticism from me would be offerring fringe players a longer deal. Byrom for example.
 
. One criticism from me would be offerring fringe players a longer deal. Byrom for example.

I can only guess that when offering Byrom a deal, he wasn't expecting the energetic emergence of both Brownhill and then Browne as 1st team / regular members of the 18 man squad.
 
I can only guess that when offering Byrom a deal, he wasn't expecting the energetic emergence of both Brownhill and then Browne as 1st team / regular members of the 18 man squad.

Another obvious question would be if SG knows his best team. His team selection lacked direction and tactical nouse in his last three games.
 
The key question is ' How highly does Uncle Trevor rate Larry?'.Hopefully he rates him highly enough to back his judgement in the transfer market with a hefty wad of cash.
Given the quality of his signings to date compared to the relatively modest outlay - if I'm right we have only shelled out cash for Browne,and at anything less than £500k for that lad he is a steal ( & a figure of around £10k seems nearer the mark) -then I think he can be trusted not to waste Uncle Trevor's cash.
Larry has built a solid defence for nothing & as someone else said - we are bloody hard to beat.
The centre of midfield looks solid & with Brownhill & Browne in there can only get better.
Larry also seems to be getting the best out of Joe Garner,but other than him,he has very little to work with in the final third of the field.
Humphrey,Holmes,Heyhurst,Beavon,Davies & Hall don't have the necessary quality to be regular starters in a championship winning team.They are all decent enough squad players who will do a job when the starter isn't available.
I'm sure that Grayson is well aware of the strengths & weaknesses within the squad - he is after all a pragmatist & I just hope that he is persuasive enough to gain the funds he needs to show that he can put out a team that is not only hard to beat,but impossible to stop from claiming the 3 points on a regular basis.
Simon Grayson - he'll do for me!
 
The key question is ' How highly does Uncle Trevor rate Larry?'.Hopefully he rates him highly enough to back his judgement in the transfer market with a hefty wad of cash.
Given the quality of his signings to date compared to the relatively modest outlay - if I'm right we have only shelled out cash for Browne,and at anything less than £500k for that lad he is a steal ( & a figure of around £10k seems nearer the mark) -then I think he can be trusted not to waste Uncle Trevor's cash.
Larry has built a solid defence for nothing & as someone else said - we are bloody hard to beat.
The centre of midfield looks solid & with Brownhill & Browne in there can only get better.
Larry also seems to be getting the best out of Joe Garner,but other than him,he has very little to work with in the final third of the field.
Humphrey,Holmes,Heyhurst,Beavon,Davies & Hall don't have the necessary quality to be regular starters in a championship winning team.They are all decent enough squad players who will do a job when the starter isn't available.
I'm sure that Grayson is well aware of the strengths & weaknesses within the squad - he is after all a pragmatist & I just hope that he is persuasive enough to gain the funds he needs to show that he can put out a team that is not only hard to beat,but impossible to stop from claiming the 3 points on a regular basis.
Simon Grayson - he'll do for me!

Good post although you must concede he exploited the loan market well with Gallagher and Kilkenny who were reportedly on significant wages.
 
Personally, I thought at the time he was appointed that he was the best candidate we could have hoped for.
I still think that he is as good as anybody else we would attract, on that basis I think he should be given at least two more years to get us back to the Championship although hopefully it will happen this coming Season.

Last Season was his first 'proper' Season. This time he has the opportunity to tweak the squad even more to his own and providing we are still strong contenders he should be given a reasonable period to transform us,.

Yes we can criticise him for being a little negative at times but to make a Team hard to beat is the first criteria,
once that is achieved the expressive side can follow.

I think he has been 7.5/10 so far and fully expect him to better that. He knows the Division and I feel that he knows our requirements and limitations, If Mr Hemmings backs the Club just a little more (and I don't think he should or would throw silly money at it) we can prosper over the next few Years.
 
Grayson is too negative for my liking, particularly at home. We drew far too many games at home, which were as a result of Grayson's tactics. Just prior to the play offs Grayson appeared to get things right at home, only to revert back to a negative line up for the play offs. Wolves were the only team to lose fewer games than us last season which suggests to me that we should have been nearer 2nd place than we were. In the end we got what we deserved.

I believe Grayson under achieved last season, and if he had allowed the team to play with more freedom, I think we would be planning a campaign back in the Championship, instead we are preparing for a 4th season in L1.

I don't believe in changing Managers, but if I was Hemmings, I would be telling Grayson that we were drawing too many games and to get it sorted. We tend to make 2 passes when 1 would suffice, which tends to exaggerate our pedestrian style. Maybe, he should allow John Dreyer more input, because he certainly put Bournemouth to the sword on his only game in charge.
 
Grayson is too negative for my liking, particularly at home. We drew far too many games at home, which were as a result of Grayson's tactics. Just prior to the play offs Grayson appeared to get things right at home, only to revert back to a negative line up for the play offs. Wolves were the only team to lose fewer games than us last season which suggests to me that we should have been nearer 2nd place than we were. In the end we got what we deserved.

I believe Grayson under achieved last season, and if he had allowed the team to play with more freedom, I think we would be planning a campaign back in the Championship, instead we are preparing for a 4th season in L1.

I don't believe in changing Managers, but if I was Hemmings, I would be telling Grayson that we were drawing too many games and to get it sorted. We tend to make 2 passes when 1 would suffice, which tends to exaggerate our pedestrian style. Maybe, he should allow John Dreyer more input, because he certainly put Bournemouth to the sword on his only game in charge.


+1
 
Grayson is too negative for my liking, particularly at home. We drew far too many games at home, which were as a result of Grayson's tactics. Just prior to the play offs Grayson appeared to get things right at home, only to revert back to a negative line up for the play offs. Wolves were the only team to lose fewer games than us last season which suggests to me that we should have been nearer 2nd place than we were. In the end we got what we deserved.

I believe Grayson under achieved last season, and if he had allowed the team to play with more freedom, I think we would be planning a campaign back in the Championship, instead we are preparing for a 4th season in L1.

I don't believe in changing Managers, but if I was Hemmings, I would be telling Grayson that we were drawing too many games and to get it sorted. We tend to make 2 passes when 1 would suffice, which tends to exaggerate our pedestrian style. Maybe, he should allow John Dreyer more input, because he certainly put Bournemouth to the sword on his only game in charge.

I actually concur but I think we need another season. He did transform a mediocre side, abeit one that would run through brick walls.
 
His achilles heel is an obsession with worrying about the opposition... and letting that influence his line up and tactics too much.

No team has ever spent so much time worrying about the opposition and gone up as champions.

It breeds fear and insecurity in the players. And it shows with every lead we've lost and every draw we turned into a last gasp defeat.

Time to man up.

Other than that.. Best since Davies.
 
Interesting how those managers deemed to be negative - Davies, Irvine and Grayson have produced much better results than those who apparently produce attacking sides who play with flair and freedom - Fergie, Brown and a tiny bit of Westley (though that's being kind).

I know which I'd prefer.

Taking his overall reign he gets a 9 from me and I fear some people have short memories. I understand the sitting back a little bit which cost us some points, but I think part of that is some fans think we have better players than we actually do.
 
Last edited:
Third he has contacts in the game and a network. It could be debated he seems to rely on players that have performed well for him at his previous clubs. As Clarke has proved this can be a plus but I wonder how inspired this is when ultimately you start guessing what ex Huddersfield player is next on the list.

Many managers sign Ex players, sometimes it doesn't work out but for us I think it has been very good. Nobody can say that the signing of Kilkenny and Clarke did not improve the squad.

His teams are set up not to lose rather than win. I really despise this tactic. It produces dull and ultimately negative football. I want to be entertained at games please Simon. I do know people like to win, I do but I hardly remember winning games with panache last Season.

Top managers do this from time to time, a perfect example is Mourinho. I argue that he was working within the squad limitations, I agree it has been frustrating how many times this season we have thrown away points because of how defensive we have become in the final few minutes of the game.

But SG made a valid point that when teams are throwing the kitchen sink at you we have to mirror it up man for man. However I believe we shouldn't get to that where we should be going into the final ten minutes of the game with a 2-3 goal advantage, but that comes down to how limited we have been as an attacking force this season.

Only Garner has broken into double figures, next season with some good signings I think will be different, we need goals from midfield next season something I hope Simon ratifies. Your not going to get them with a CM partnership of Kilkenny and Welsh.

I like the way we get good press now but I feel that Radio Lancs and the E post tend to lose their critical faculties when interviewing him and act like friends rather than impartial sports journalists (has SG done a fans forum yet).

I would like a fans forum.

He must go one better and deliver promotion next season. I think possibly only Alan Irvine has been backed as well in recent years by Hemmings.
My overall view on his tenure so far is about 6/10.

Promotion is a must next season otherwise he has failed, I think we will be one of the favourites with the division being weaker and us building on already strong foundations.

I would rate his tenure so far as 8/10.

To stop us being relegated to turn us around into one of the hardest teams to beat in the league without spending a penny on transfer fees is a magnificent job. He has one of the best records as a manager for us so far so you can't fault that.
 
Back
Top