Skip to main content

The Engine Room

The Engine Room

Joined
Apr 27, 2006
Messages
17,335
Location
Lurking in the shadows
Johnson Browne Gallagher - are they beginning to purr or still stuttering along.

They are improving as a group in my opinion and certainly improving individually in the case of Johnson and Browne.

Johnson - sweet left foot, still lightweight in the tackle and tends to play the same sort of football wherever he is on the pitch...thats fine in their half but loses the ball too often in potentially dangerous situations. PS - best 50 grand we have ever spent. PPS must try to head the ball soon!!!

Browne - not a superstar yet but improving every game, good engine, hard tackler, just needs some more experience and guidance......wasn`t afraid to show Barton who was boss yesterday.

Gallagher - new lease of life for me in his deeper play maker role, tackling has improved this season as has his presence on the ball. Challenges Garner for the Talisman role at the club and still quality in my opinion.

All three are suited to the current 3-5-2 we are playing ....very encouraging.
 
The Engine Room

Think Johnson isn't the best tackler but he tracks back well, stays tight to a man on holds the shape of the team well - one of the reasons why we are solid and tough to crack is due to our shape and discipline.

Browne had got lots of time on his side and for me can do most things you need of a cm. With Gally and DJ pushing on he wont get on the scoresheet as much as he has more of a defensive duty. But for ROI u21s and 18s he has popped up with a number of goals in a more attacking role. He'll become a very good player imo.

Gallagher is one of the best players we have - end of.
 
Gallagher unfortunately is a flat track bully. Never quite been good enough to mix it at the top level. Bowne however has a look of of a young Bobby Charlton. With Grayson looking after him he will become an absolute star
 
I think of Browne and Johnson it will be Browne that we sell for more money. He is fast becoming a good box-to-box midfielder with lots of technique. If he can add a little finesse to his game a la Johnson he will make it in the Prem.
 
If you harass the opposition and block them from making the obvious pass, you don't need to be tackling. Johnson does this extremely well IMO and what a sweet left foot. He's only just turned 23 so will improve further.

This season was all about consilidating, but if we still have Johnson & Browne with us next season (and I can't see any reason why not) we could be in for a really exciting season.
 
If you harass the opposition and block them from making the obvious pass, you don't need to be tackling. Johnson does this extremely well IMO and what a sweet left foot. He's only just turned 23 so will improve further.

This season was all about consilidating, but if we still have Johnson & Browne with us next season (and I can't see any reason why not) we could be in for a really exciting season.

Love it when people can spell exciting
 
To be honest I have hated seeing Gally sat in front of the defence. He is the softest player we have and tackling has never been his strong point. He is our most dangerous and creative player and to have him stuck deep seems like a huge misuse of his skills, in my opinion. Yesterday it all clicked though, whether that has been the case all along and I couldn't see it or it just happened to work out on the day I don't know but fair dues to him.

As for Browne I have been impressed with him more often than not this season, he goes about the game doing the simple things well. It's the cliched stuff but as you say, he has a good engine and will stick a foot in. What I like about him the most is he doesn't shy away in games, even when he fucks up he is always involved.
 
Johnson Browne Gallagher - are they beginning to purr or still stuttering along.

They are improving as a group in my opinion and certainly improving individually in the case of Johnson and Browne.

Johnson - sweet left foot, still lightweight in the tackle and tends to play the same sort of football wherever he is on the pitch...thats fine in their half but loses the ball too often in potentially dangerous situations. PS - best 50 grand we have ever spent. PPS must try to head the ball soon!!!

Browne - not a superstar yet but improving every game, good engine, hard tackler, just needs some more experience and guidance......wasn`t afraid to show Barton who was boss yesterday.

Gallagher - new lease of life for me in his deeper play maker role, tackling has improved this season as has his presence on the ball. Challenges Garner for the Talisman role at the club and still quality in my opinion.

All three are suited to the current 3-5-2 we are playing ....very encouraging.

Agreed, save that DJ has still got some way to go before he can be considered to be a better 50 grand purchase than Grezza!
 
Johnson Browne Gallagher - are they beginning to purr or still stuttering along.

They are improving as a group in my opinion and certainly improving individually in the case of Johnson and Browne.

Johnson - sweet left foot, still lightweight in the tackle and tends to play the same sort of football wherever he is on the pitch...thats fine in their half but loses the ball too often in potentially dangerous situations. PS - best 50 grand we have ever spent. PPS must try to head the ball soon!!!

Browne - not a superstar yet but improving every game, good engine, hard tackler, just needs some more experience and guidance......wasn`t afraid to show Barton who was boss yesterday.

Gallagher - new lease of life for me in his deeper play maker role, tackling has improved this season as has his presence on the ball. Challenges Garner for the Talisman role at the club and still quality in my opinion.

All three are suited to the current 3-5-2 we are playing ....very encouraging.

Great post

Burnley was first time I've seen Johnson give ball away often, usually I have to say he is very good at not doing so, but yeah....heading needs work!
 
From what ive seen i like the shape. Having Reach pinned on the touchline a la john robertson gives our midfield more room to play.
 
Johnson Browne Gallagher - are they beginning to purr or still stuttering along.

They are improving as a group in my opinion and certainly improving individually in the case of Johnson and Browne.

Johnson - sweet left foot, still lightweight in the tackle and tends to play the same sort of football wherever he is on the pitch...thats fine in their half but loses the ball too often in potentially dangerous situations. PS - best 50 grand we have ever spent. PPS must try to head the ball soon!!!

Browne - not a superstar yet but improving every game, good engine, hard tackler, just needs some more experience and guidance......wasn`t afraid to show Barton who was boss yesterday.

Gallagher - new lease of life for me in his deeper play maker role, tackling has improved this season as has his presence on the ball. Challenges Garner for the Talisman role at the club and still quality in my opinion.

All three are suited to the current 3-5-2 we are playing ....very encouraging.

Agree they are suited to the 352. They aren't the most combatative central three so the two wing backs allow them to squeeze play and utilise the ability on the ball that both Gally and DJ possess in spades.

Browne is benefiting from an extended run and learning all he time. He has a great engine and works box to box very well. Good to see him get a shot off on Saturday which Heaton saved well.

Gallagher stepped up a gear when he game back on loan under Grayson in League One. For me, he has stepped up another gear now he is back in the Championship. When he plays well, we do well as a team. On Saturday his cross field distribution was excellent and opened up play. He isn't a natural tackler but has worked hard to improve this aspect of the game and it shows. Key play maker for me.

DJ is very good in possession because he is capable of holding the ball and running with it. Sometimes his distribution is too ambitious and can result in a misplaced pass. Remember, he is our leading scorer this season and it's a natural part of his game. Physically he needs to strengthen and I'm sure the coaching team will work on that aspect of his game.

Put the three together and it highlights the quality in playmaking which is at the heart of our game and that 352 formation. No surprise for me that it has worked so well for us away from home when it comes into its own. For me it highlights why comments about negative tactics are off the mark.

The bigger challenge is how to harness that midfield quality into a more offensive home approach since we don't have the offensive right sided player to balance a different formation. When Humphrey is fit and on his game that partially addresses the issue but I'd make that slot a priority for strengthening.
 
Put the three together and it highlights the quality in playmaking which is at the heart of our game and that 352 formation. No surprise for me that it has worked so well for us away from home when it comes into its own. For me it highlights why comments about negative tactics are off the mark.

The bigger challenge is how to harness that midfield quality into a more offensive home approach since we don't have the offensive right sided player to balance a different formation. When Humphrey is fit and on his game that partially addresses the issue but I'd make that slot a priority for strengthening.

It is the combination of all three of Gallagher, Johnson and Browne together that gives us a central midfield with enough skill and just enough strength to make that wing-back formation work - any two of them would leave us short. What we lack is a really forceful central midfielder and that is the reason why at the moment we cannot play a flat four-man midfield - the lack of a right-sided player is neither here nor there. On the latter count the return of Humphrey - though it will give us a potentially useful extra option for the right-sided wing-back role - will do nothing for our attacking potential in home games as he simply does not have the skill to operate as a 'winger'.
 
Lets stop messing around, Johnson does not tackle (alright he made one on Saturday).

He backs out or even slows down so that he doesn't put himself in a position where he would be expected to tackle.

Once the opposition suss this out he can be a liabilty, so he is not the type of player we want on the pitch when we're a man down or we have our backs to the wall.

This is possibly the reason he only cost £50,000.
 
Browne is improving and will only get stronger but for me, we still need a more physical and pacy centre midfielder with experience.
 
Which to add some balance was in the Derby half of the pitch. It's not like he gave possession away at the edge of our box.

Not only was it in the Derby half of the pitch but practically straight at Welsh, who for some reason failed to even try to control it.
 
It is the combination of all three of Gallagher, Johnson and Browne together that gives us a central midfield with enough skill and just enough strength to make that wing-back formation work - any two of them would leave us short. What we lack is a really forceful central midfielder and that is the reason why at the moment we cannot play a flat four-man midfield - the lack of a right-sided player is neither here nor there. On the latter count the return of Humphrey - though it will give us a potentially useful extra option for the right-sided wing-back role - will do nothing for our attacking potential in home games as he simply does not have the skill to operate as a 'winger'.

A 433 allows you to play the same midfield 3 but it still leaves the hole on the right side of the front three. Or you could play a 4411 with Johnson in the advanced midfield role. I'm not arguing against another strong midfielder as cover for Browne when Welsh eventually moves on but it isn't as big a priority as the attacking wide right position IMHO.
 
Back
Top