Skip to main content

The Engine Room

The Engine Room

A 433 allows you to play the same midfield 3 but it still leaves the hole on the right side of the front three. Or you could play a 4411 with Johnson in the advanced midfield role. I'm not arguing against another strong midfielder as cover for Browne when Welsh eventually moves on but it isn't as big a priority as the attacking wide right position IMHO.

Not if the right-back can get up in support of the attack - which Vermilj can do though he is not as good defensively as Woods. But even if we did bring in a new right-sided midfielder to enable us to play 4.4.2 then, as I said, we don't have two central midfielders who by themselves can run the central midfield - without the support of Browne a pairing of Gallagher and Johnson would be overrun. Sorry but the 4.4.1.1 idea is utterly futile - you are effectively saying we should drastically reduce Garner's effectiveness by playing him as a lone striker just to bring in a right winger. The only four-at-the-back formation that would work for us at the moment is a 4.3.3 with Reach pushed forward to play alongside a strike pairing of Garner and someone else. Nothing to stop Reach being played on the right to allow Cunningham the space to get forward if need be.
 
Johnson - sweet left foot, still lightweight in the tackle and tends to play the same sort of football wherever he is on the pitch...thats fine in their half but loses the ball too often in potentially dangerous situations. PS - best 50 grand we have ever spent. PPS must try to head the ball soon!!!

Photo courtesy of KIPAX.

4gbYvrT.jpg


Take that!
 
johnson browne gallagher - are they beginning to purr or still stuttering along.

They are improving as a group in my opinion and certainly improving individually in the case of johnson and browne.

Johnson - sweet left foot, still lightweight in the tackle and tends to play the same sort of football wherever he is on the pitch...thats fine in their half but loses the ball too often in potentially dangerous situations. Ps - best 50 grand we have ever spent. Pps must try to head the ball soon!!!

Browne - not a superstar yet but improving every game, good engine, hard tackler, just needs some more experience and guidance......wasn`t afraid to show barton who was boss yesterday.

Gallagher - new lease of life for me in his deeper play maker role, tackling has improved this season as has his presence on the ball. Challenges garner for the talisman role at the club and still quality in my opinion.

All three are suited to the current 3-5-2 we are playing ....very encouraging.
for me browne has no place in that three...should be welsh...FORGOT TO ADD IN ADDITION HE`S WEAK AS PISS
 
Not if the right-back can get up in support of the attack - which Vermilj can do though he is not as good defensively as Woods. But even if we did bring in a new right-sided midfielder to enable us to play 4.4.2 then, as I said, we don't have two central midfielders who by themselves can run the central midfield - without the support of Browne a pairing of Gallagher and Johnson would be overrun. Sorry but the 4.4.1.1 idea is utterly futile - you are effectively saying we should drastically reduce Garner's effectiveness by playing him as a lone striker just to bring in a right winger. The only four-at-the-back formation that would work for us at the moment is a 4.3.3 with Reach pushed forward to play alongside a strike pairing of Garner and someone else. Nothing to stop Reach being played on the right to allow Cunningham the space to get forward if need be.

I know you have strong views on a central midfielder to replace Welsh. My view is that is not the first priority. I won't repeat the arguments I've made earlier in the thread since repetition is the bane of this forum.

Grayson has demonstrated how to use different formations over the past couple of seasons. The record tells us that each has had different measures of success, including 4411. More importantly, Grayson has tried to teach his team to be flexible in games and adjust formation when required. Jamie Hoyland on RL on Saturday contrasted Grayson's tactically flexibility to Dyche's inflexibility. At the moment we lack an offensive right sided player, preferably one with pace. Such a player would add flexibility to our squad and gives us additional options, including within a game.

I guess we'll just have to differ on the priorities but I'm fine leaving it to Grayson to make the call. 😉
 
I can't believe how Gally has improved his tackling and heading since he's been moved in front of the defence. It gives him the chance to spread the play from there. Dj is always a threat from further forward and Browne has surpassed Welsh, Kilkenny and Brownhill with his recent displays. Burnley's midfield of Boyd, Jones, Barton and Arfield came off 2nd best against our lads which really surprised me on the day as I thought they would have too much aggression and energy.
 
Lets stop messing around, Johnson does not tackle (alright he made one on Saturday).

He backs out or even slows down so that he doesn't put himself in a position where he would be expected to tackle.

Once the opposition suss this out he can be a liabilty, so he is not the type of player we want on the pitch when we're a man down or we have our backs to the wall.

This is possibly the reason he only cost £50,000.

The only reason he cost £50k is because Lambert made a terrible error of judgement.

I would be surprised if he left here for less than £5m.

He has 6 league goals to his name already this season and on the ball is probably the most gifted midfielder i have seen in the shirt in my time watching (over 25 years).
 
The only reason he cost £50k is because Lambert made a terrible error of judgement.

I would be surprised if he left here for less than £5m.

He has 6 league goals to his name already this season and on the ball is probably the most gifted midfielder i have seen in the shirt in my time watching (over 25 years).

We keep talking about this £50k, but that doesn't really mean much in these Bosman days - I'm yet to see anything which confirms how much he is costing in terms of wages.
 
I have to say I think DJ is really the weakest of our midfield - sure he has scored a few goals and has a wicked left foot just outside the area, but over the past few games he consistently has failed to complete passes, giving away possession and leaving us exposed to the counter. I think I can count on my right hand the number of tackles I've seen him made. He never looks like winning the ball in an aerial challenge.

It's not that he isn't a bargain for £50k, he's just not as good as many seem to think. He's a young lad and has time to develop and I hope he keeps doing so, but tbh I think he needs to show some real improvement in some areas of his game to be a central part of our team if we are to push up the league in later seasons.
 
I have to say I think DJ is really the weakest of our midfield - sure he has scored a few goals and has a wicked left foot just outside the area, but over the past few games he consistently has failed to complete passes, giving away possession and leaving us exposed to the counter. I think I can count on my right hand the number of tackles I've seen him made. He never looks like winning the ball in an aerial challenge.

It's not that he isn't a bargain for £50k, he's just not as good as many seem to think. He's a young lad and has time to develop and I hope he keeps doing so, but tbh I think he needs to show some real improvement in some areas of his game to be a central part of our team if we are to push up the league in later seasons.

He's an attacking midfielder who is being asked to play much, much deeper than he is used to.

His defensive game has noticably improved since he first arrived and although he's not much of a tackler, his pressing and hassling of the opposition is great. Beckford's hat trick goal springs to mind in terms of Johnson winning the ball in the middle of the park.

A Dingle who I know said he would love to have him at Turf Moor based on what he saw on Saturday and I thought he had a poor first half personally.

If he played in a team what could afford to give him a free role behind the strikers then he would be one of the stand out players in the division imo.
 
He's an attacking midfielder who is being asked to play much, much deeper than he is used to.


If he played in a team what could afford to give him a free role behind the strikers then he would be one of the stand out players in the division imo.

Exactly - but that is the role in which Gallagher can excel as well but they can't both play it at the same time. But if we play Johnson behind the strikers and have Gallagher sitting further back then we need more strength than Vermilj, Browne and Reach can collectively provide in support - however well each of those may play at an individual level. At the moment the only central midfield we can put out with both enough skill and - just barely - enough strength is one with all three of Browne, Gallagher and Johnson close together. Unless and until we bring in some quality reinforcement to the midfield that will remain the case.
 
Apparently Tom Clarke often played in the holding role at Huddersfield where many say it was his best position

My mate is a Huddersfield fan and the first thing he said to me when we signed him was that Clarke had his best spell for them when playing in midfield. Obviously that was in League One though.
 
Back
Top