Skip to main content

The left back decison.....

The left back decison.....

Poll Poll The left back decison.....


  • Total voters
    173
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think the decision to be made is which one goes because we don't need 3, ,especially with young Anderton in the background also.
 
Personally I think our biggest current concern is not so much the players but the whole team set up. 5 across the middle one up front and two left backs in an unbalanced team is wrong. Grayson needs telling people are not enjoying matches with little or no attacking threat.
All three left backs are ok but ok isn't going to be enough. Personally I'd play Laird in his true left wing back role at home but its not the left back that people come to watch. Entertain/Attack another night where kids on for a quid were totally unimpressed.
 
Buchanan. Surprised when he was dropped after a good run of form last season. He's not had a look in since. Hopefully , Larry will give him another chance but I doubt it will happen.
 
Not the best going forward, but for me, Buchanan is solid and wouldn't have let Campell-rice play like he did on Saturday.
 
I won't cast a vote since for me I believe it's more about the team than the individual. Where we are looking to take the game to the opposition - especially at home - I'd play Laird since he gives the team more attacking options as he raids from deep (we saw a couple of good runs in the second half last night).

Where we are looking to keep solid and lock down a strong back four, then Buchanan is usually pretty competent. Can't see any point in having two decent left backs with different strengths if we don't utilise those differences to suit the requirements at the time.

Young Ben has lots of potential but clearly needs more development time to step ahead of his two more experienced competitors. I'd loan him out to a L2 side for three months and see what transpires.
 
Buchanan woth davies as cover. He is still raw and has plenty to learn but he also has age on his side, ship laird out.
 
With the ruling about x number of players in a JPT game having to have played in the match before/after I wouldn't be surprised if Buchanan keeps hold of the LB slot.

Laird hasn't rediscovered his form since the leg break and Davies is still 12 months away from being ready imo.
 
Those voting numbers speak volumes.
I went with Laird, however the argument for Buchanan is a strong one. What is obvious though is the lack of voting for Davies. The issue with dropping him now is that his confidence could end up being well and truly dented. Larry should have stuck with either Laird or Buchanan from the start but that isn't really constructive as no turning back the clock. How this plays out will be interesting....
 
I bet he'd've had a few if the poll had been run last week.

Probably, and there aren't many wingers like JCR in this division, but I highly doubt that anyone on here would have picked Davies as their first choice LB at the start of the season.

Buchanan for me.

FWIW I'd have played Davies at LCB last night with Huntington.
 
For me I want my left back to defend, and in buchs you probably have one of the best in league 1 at doing that, very solid left back great pro and it's worrying the club were going to let him leave, for me he's the best left back at the club it's not even close.

If I was to loan one out it would be laird,would say he would be the biggest wage of the 3, and he's lost a few yards of pace.
 
Buchanan isn't good enough. His performance in the play offs last season was absolutely abysmal.

Give Laird a good run of games, I reckon he will be back to his best. Since Grayson has taken over, he has either kept swapping the left backs or played Laird out of position, which has not helped him at all to get back to his best.
 
Can't believe anyone's voted for Buchanan, worst of the three by an absolute mile. He's like a rabbit in headlights when he sees the halfway line
 
Laird all-day long for me.

Just as good as Buchanan defensively but actually crosses the halfway line in the process. Good cross on him and isn't afraid to get in the box. Plus he takes a good corner.

It's not his fault Grayson rarely uses him as an actual left back.
 
Probably, and there aren't many wingers like JCR in this division, but I highly doubt that anyone on here would have picked Davies as their first choice LB at the start of the season.
TBH, I was happy for him to be first-choice at the start of the season, as I think we need to bring these young players on, and they'll only get that vital experience from starting first-team games for us, not sitting on the bench or in the stands.

The risk with starting the youngsters though, is they will inevitably be inconsistent, and they will make mistakes, lots of them, potentially big ones, because they're still learning.

The upside is, you potentially get a bunch of good young first-team players out the other end.

Hopefully SG can manage these players appropriately, and we won't end up in a situation where all the kids are starting on the bench, or sitting in the stands, because all the old lags are filling the first-team slots.
 
Buchanan isn't good enough. His performance in the play offs last season was absolutely abysmal.

Give Laird a good run of games, I reckon he will be back to his best. Since Grayson has taken over, he has either kept swapping the left backs or played Laird out of position, which has not helped him at all to get back to his best.

Agreed - though in fairness to Buchanan he was played in the play-off second leg in that 'wing'back' role where he is even more woefully than Laird. From what little I have seen of Laird on video this season he looks to need to lose a bit of weight but he can support the attack much better than Buchanan and given that they are roughlycomparable as defenders that tips the scale in Laird's favour.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top