Skip to main content

The left back decison.....

The left back decison.....

Poll Poll The left back decison.....


  • Total voters
    173
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
In a 442 or the formation we been playing of late I'd want the left sided attacking player to have the freedom to attack whether that be Little, Gallagher or Reid. In that case I'd want the strongest defender there which for me in Buchanan.
 
Left or right back are specialist positions. Best left back at the club for me is Buchanan and his name should be one of the first on the team sheet for every game.
 
Pre-injury Laird was in my view the best player at the club. He hasn't unfortunately been anything like the same player post injury, but I'd still (just) pick him ahead of Buchanan on the basis that he offers something going forward.

Hopefully Davies will be a good player in the future but will have his confidence ripped to shreds if he gets exposed too early, as on Saturday. I'd prefer if we used either Laird or Buchanan as first choice with Davies as back up. as we clearly don't need three left backs, one of the experienced two needs to go out on loan, and given the lack of left backs generally (we've had a shortage in that position for most of the last 20 years) I'd hope they could find somewhere.
 
We want promotion this season and that means picking the strongest player now. Ben Davies will no doubt be the best in 5 years and still be relatively young, but right now I'd pick Buchanan. He played out of his skin last night, but was he trying to impress for a loan move out of Deepdale? Laird seems to be above him in the pecking order, as well as Davies.
 
Buchanan all day long for me, ship laird out permanently and keep davies for the future and hope to god he improves massively
 
Whilst he's not reached the standards he produced prior to his broken leg I've still voted Laird.... Mainly because he's the best we have as a left back ( in a back 4 ) that constantly pushes forward and gives us a more attacking approach....... Trouble is, Grayson wouldn't want him going past the half way line too often... Gung Ho fullbacks?.. Heaven Forbid !! 🙂
 
Buchanan for me currently but I have an open mind about all 3. Davies for the future certainly and Laird when Grayson decideds to go with wing backs....however if its four at the back its Buchs for me right now.
 
Buchanan isn't good enough. His performance in the play offs last season was absolutely abysmal.


Give Laird a good run of games, I reckon he will be back to his best. Since Grayson has taken over, he has either kept swapping the left backs or played Laird out of position, which has not helped him at all to get back to his best.

Can't believe anyone's voted for Buchanan, worst of the three by an absolute mile. He's like a rabbit in headlights when he sees the halfway line

Laird for me everytime.. give him a run of games in his left back position not left midfield... i think Buchanan will be out on loan soon.
 
Its a bit unfair to have a poll the week after Davies had a horror show and no surprise he is gaining no support. (Straight after the Notts County game I doubt Woods would have had much support either if we were discussing right backs)

My concern with Laird is three fold: 1) he hasn't looked the same since his leg break, 2) his style really doesnt suit Grayson's back four system where full backs primarily defend and 3) he was someone who followed Westley at multiple clubs and that just worrys me as a choice of mentor. The other issue is Laird may be a high earner who Grayson feels we can do without.

Buchanen is the obvious option if Grayson chooses to bench Davies, simply because he is very straightforward. He sits and defends and usually stays tight to his man. He does things the simple way and takes few risks (unlike Wiseman and his weekly attempts at nightmare /underhit back passes). As an attacking threat he is pretty much a non entity but if we are looking at just asking him to give the ball to Reid maybe that is all that is required.
 
Not one vote for young Ben.

Speaks volumes.

Typically what you'd expect to see on a thread of this nature....

I bet he'd've had a few if the poll had been run last week.

Exactly & one of those no doubt would have been Sports Lawyer....

Give Laird a good run of games, I reckon he will be back to his best. Since Grayson has taken over, he has either kept swapping the left backs or played Laird out of position, which has not helped him at all to get back to his best.

Exactly my thoughts.
 
I think that all three have some very good qualities.

It isn't just about who plays or even the formation that we plan to play.

Who will be playing around them has a big bearing on who I would pick.

If SG insists on playing Gallagher in the wide left berth, I don't think we have any option other than Buchanan to sit behind him.

Haven't seen Reid yet, so don't know which of the 3 would play best with him.

Before his injury I would definitely have rated Laird the best of the 3, and he may come good again, but if we want to be at the top of the table, we can't give him too many chances to prove it if he doesn't deliver.

Clearly Davies has talent but has a steep learning curve to get through at the moment, because a lot of his decision making is atrocious. If he can learn (and some players like Trotman never do) then we will have a very good player on our hands.
 
I think that all three have some very good qualities.

It isn't just about who plays or even the formation that we plan to play.

Who will be playing around them has a big bearing on who I would pick.

If SG insists on playing Gallagher in the wide left berth, I don't think we have any option other than Buchanan to sit behind him.

Haven't seen Reid yet, so don't know which of the 3 would play best with him.

Before his injury I would definitely have rated Laird the best of the 3, and he may come good again, but if we want to be at the top of the table, we can't give him too many chances to prove it if he doesn't deliver.

Clearly Davies has talent but has a steep learning curve to get through at the moment, because a lot of his decision making is atrocious. If he can learn (and some players like Trotman never do) then we will have a very good player on our hands.

Cant agree with it depending on who plays around them. Back four are there to defend....how would Laird feel, for example, if his place in the team was dependant on Gallagher playing in front of him.......hardly motivation to perform well if you know that if Gallagher doesnt play then you dont play. Not very good man management I would suggest.

Pick who you like at left back but dont make it linked to who plays wide left.......in fact when you think about it Grayson changes his wide men constantly from left to right.....giving even more strength to the argument of just picking the best man for the job.
 
Laird is our best left-back technically, just needs to find his form again. Been in and out of the team too much recently. He offers so much more going forward, can whip in a decent cross and can score, too. Buchs is solid but nothing special imo.
 
I think it's a case of horses for courses.

If we need a solid left back in a 442, then it's Buchanan. I have not seen enough of Davies to comment, but Scott Laird would be my preference if an overlapping full back or wing back is needed.

Personally, I don't think Laird has recovered the form he showed for us prior to breaking his leg. If he hits levels again, he's the obvious first choice.
 
The pre-injury Laird is head and shoulders above the other two. Pretty much the complete modern-day full back.

Personally, I think his ability justifies giving him a good two or three months to show if he's going to get back to that level.

Given also that Davies is still developing I don't think we can properly judge the three of them right now.
 
Buchanan cannot cross the ball for toffee!

Laird all day long for me plus he has the added bonus of having goals in him.
 
Buchanan cannot cross the ball for toffee!

Laird all day long for me plus he has the added bonus of having goals in him.

I'm surprised you don't remember his cross for Davies to score last season. It was an excellent cross and should be memorable because it was one of the few goals Davies scored. I can't remember who it was against though!

I think Buchanan is decent going forward and does get some good crosses in. Unlike Laird, who invariably cuts inside, Buchanan has the ability to get close to the bye-line on the outside of the defender.
 
Lol when was the last time laird scored ???
He no pace and to slow

He scored many times pre injury. Scored a goal last season vs Stevenage, as well as a great goal this pre season.

He's not prolific by any means, but playing consistently which allows him to be at his best, he will chip in with the odd goal every now and then.

I don't think I can remember Buchanan scoring ever in his whole time at the club.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top