The Ryan Lowe Thread!
We ain't gonna sack him till end of season earliest guaranteed
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2011
- Messages
- 6,539
They are far from what would be described by most as decent chances. It's very unlikely that a header from that position results in a goal, and the majority shots from that position of Millar do not result in a goal. Hence why the xG on the two shots are low.Because both our goals were decent chances. Browne's was a pretty much unchallenged header in the middle of the box - it's a great chance. Millar's was a good angle and he'd scored from an almost identical position a few days earlier.
12 out of 20 premier League teams are currently "outperforming" their xg - it's one of many metrics, to be used in conjunction with lots of others, never in isolation.
We've outperformed our xG because we've actually been finishing the odd chances we get this season, compared to last season when we missed plenty. The issue being the amount of good chances (which converts to xG) we are creating, whilst also conceding a boat load of goals along with it.
Correct, xG shouldn't be used in isolation, but it backs up the claims and the results.
Spot on Gaz...Opposition supporters are always in general welcomed on the forum so long as they don't act like a knob (you clearly aren't one btw).
However, your initial posts came across as a little patronising and we've had enough of that on here recently from two dingbats (one of whom has thankfully be fucked off). That coupled with our recent form, standard of football etc means a lot of us are a little angry at the moment so won't accept being lectured to.
I know you mean well, but it does help to look into things first and gauge why fans feel the way they do.
Unfortunately you fell into the common trap of just looking into the league position and judging that everything is ok based on that. It never tells the full story.
Like you, i dont think " Green Army " is a knob but as you have articulately pointed out to him, its not about our league position , its about the dire performances on the pitch , the turgid football that Lowe serves up and that coupled with his arrogant comments about the fans and about the players, its never his fault..........
Outsiders dont see that !!
And then bring a new manager in for our League 1 campaign ?We ain't gonna sack him till end of season earliest guaranteed
Complete negligence and ‘heads-in-the-sand’ from the ownership. That should have been the last straw against Sunderland, after the shite form and standard of football over Xmas, it just needed a result and some form of ‘fight’.
There was neither, in any other team/league the manager would be gone on the same day or the day after (see Birmingham). This is now on CH/PR continuing to let this go on, completely useless. Zero trust in any of them.
There was neither, in any other team/league the manager would be gone on the same day or the day after (see Birmingham). This is now on CH/PR continuing to let this go on, completely useless. Zero trust in any of them.
- Joined
- Nov 21, 2012
- Messages
- 788
For a population of 5,000 a good response rate for indicative return is c.900 people responding.To also be fair, I think 4% is quite representative in a poll.
For example, in the likely May general election, you would have to get the opinion of nearly 2 million voters to equate to 4% of those entitled to vote.
- Joined
- May 16, 2014
- Messages
- 2,425
One can hope…. And that would be the best choice in our predicamentReturn of the King?
Yep. Going nowhere. The joys of unambitious owners
The replies to that are unequivocal so far.
Lowe has really shot himself in the foot with recent comments.
Well done Brum and Jasper carrot!
Big name or no big name, scouser rooney despatched within 15 games while our lot dither and give a vote of confidence after 2 years of Bullshit!
Lets see if Rivett/Hemmings has the acumen to pull the trigger or behave like a small time charlie!
Big name or no big name, scouser rooney despatched within 15 games while our lot dither and give a vote of confidence after 2 years of Bullshit!
Lets see if Rivett/Hemmings has the acumen to pull the trigger or behave like a small time charlie!
I disagree, I think xg is extremely limited. Browne's header is a great chance because: he's virtually unchallenged, he is running onto the ball, and he's very good at hitting the target in those positions. Does xg take any of that into account? If not, I can't really see what it offers.They are far from what would be described by most as decent chances. It's very unlikely that a header from that position results in a goal, and the majority shots from that position of Millar do not result in a goal. Hence why the xG on the two shots are low.
We've outperformed our xG because we've actually been finishing the odd chances we get this season, compared to last season when we missed plenty. The issue being the amount of good chances (which converts to xG) we are creating, whilst also conceding a boat load of goals along with it.
Correct, xG shouldn't be used in isolation, but it backs up the claims and the results.
- Joined
- Feb 20, 2022
- Messages
- 488
I hope this isnt taken the wrong way but 14 votes is currently 2.4%.I cant believe that 14 people have voted for him to stay..........
Surely they must be Lashers or Plastics or Family.........
In society 2.14% of people have learning difficulties or do not have the mental capacity to make sane decisions so it seems about correct
Also 4% is generally the 'Lizardman's constant'I hope this isnt taken the wrong way but 14 votes is currently 2.4%.
In society 2.14% of people have learning difficulties or do not have the mental capacity to make sane decisions so it seems about correct
"In the 2013 post "Lizardman's Constant is 4%," Alexander coined the term "Lizardman's Constant," referring to the approximate percentage of responses to a poll, survey, or quiz that are not sincere."
To be at 2.3% Lowe in is decent.
Had a decent run of 2 years to produce.
More than most get.
I backed him. The Club backed him.
Nov 28th when I posted these 6 little words "Cannot - and will not - defend that" was a major turning point for myself.
He had a go and it isn't working.
Time To Go with our Best Wishes.
More than most get.
I backed him. The Club backed him.
Nov 28th when I posted these 6 little words "Cannot - and will not - defend that" was a major turning point for myself.
He had a go and it isn't working.
Time To Go with our Best Wishes.
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2019
- Messages
- 53,978
Best wishes
All the best to you too 👍
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2011
- Messages
- 6,539
"An xG model uses historical information from thousands of shots with similar characteristics to estimate the likelihood of a goal on a scale between 0 and 1. For example, a shot with an xG value of 0.2 is one that we would generally expect to be converted twice in every 10 attempts."I disagree, I think xg is extremely limited. Browne's header is a great chance because: he's virtually unchallenged, he is running onto the ball, and he's very good at hitting the target in those positions. Does xg take any of that into account? If not, I can't really see what it offers.
It doesn't matter about the individual taking the shot when xG is calculated. A header from just outside the penalty spot is never going to be classed as a great chance, unless there's no GK, as the majority of headers that are closer to goal than that do not result in a goal so that's why the xG for that shot is so low.
The game against Huddersfield, we only created one good chance. Browne then scored a worldie header and Whiteman scored from the edge of the box. So yes we scored 3, but only one was a good chance.
I think you're letting the outcome of those shots out way the bigger picture of the frequency you see attempts like that actually go in.
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2023
- Messages
- 27
I get it.For what it's worth I like hearing different opinions and I'm happy to have you here as long as you're here in good faith. I don't have an issue with the initial question either, I don't personally keep on top of the various bits of drama going on at other clubs so I would be curious too. I'm not particularly bothered if you are trying to wind us up either because it's an opportunity to explain to fans of other teams who might be reading and have the same genuine question.
Just keep in mind the context that you've asked at a time where:
1) People are really fed up of Lowe. Some longer than others including as far back as last season. For most I feel like the point of no return was the Watford game (so about a month ago).
2) We've had at least two fans who have asked the same question as you however it is largely believed they haven't asked in good faith and have taken the opportunity to tell us we don't deserve better. A particularly sore point because we haven't been in the top flight since the 60's yet have seen a number of teams move past us (a pain I'm sure you can empathize with as a Plymouth fan) and because Peter Ridsdale's method of communication often has a similar demeanor.
I'm hope you can understand why people would be somewhat understandably defensive or fed up of repeating the same points again and again. Time will tell if you're a good'un, just keep acting in good faith. We've had a few opposition fans on here that are very welcome to chat over the years, would be good to have a Plymouth fan's perspective too.
I hadn’t realised it was so toxic here.
I was delighted when Risdale left as our chairman so you have my sympathies there.
It seems it’s time for a fresh start and it seems you need a manager who buys into the fabric of the club.
Welcome home 🤍💙Had a decent run of 2 years to produce.
More than most get.
I backed him. The Club backed him.
Nov 28th when I posted these 6 little words "Cannot - and will not - defend that" was a major turning point for myself.
He had a go and it isn't working.
Time To Go with our Best Wishes.