Skip to main content

The Ryan Lowe Thread!

The Ryan Lowe Thread!

Without being rude, XG is a much better performance indicator than say league position. Results do not give as clear an indicator as performance. That's why it's used globally by clubs, whether fans like it or not is irrelevant because XG is relevant.

You say it'd not something we need to look at, I said weeks ago when we were doing well we were going to sink like a stone because the goals are just not going to keep coming.

Let's take Huddersfield. I said at the time we were extremely lucky to score three goals in that. We are not taking enough shots or creating enough. Even against Leeds it's a moment of magic from Millar that ultimately scores the goal. I knew both games would be low XG.

Watch Liverpool highlights from last night. That's a performance that was always going to create victory. Newcastle were lucky to get two and were clinical just like we've been all season. You have to create chances, XG will show you are. It's a totally fair and factual criticism. Just saying 'I don't like it' is fine but that ultimately doesn't mean anything.
No, I'm being massively misquoted there. I'm saying everything else is bad enough without needing to use a less reliable metric in isolation. I stand by my point that xg in isolation doesn't mean much. The fact that 12 Prem teams are currently "outperforming" it supports my view (make it 10 if you take away a couple that are very close to it).
Xg is one metric to be used along with many others.
 
I was delighted when Risdale left as our chairman so you have my sympathies there.

It seems it’s time for a fresh start and it seems you need a manager who buys into the fabric of the club.

Hey no worries, I think if I were in your position I'd be asking the same questions too.

You've hit on another discussion point here too. I suspect if you read around here a bit some people would say sacking Lowe achieves nothing as Ridsdale and the ownership are still here.

Ridsdale in particular takes a lot of the blame because he's been here for a decade. I certainly hold him accountable for a lot of the club culture and financial decisions. It's ridiculous that we build so much around the manager for example and how much we outsource IMO.

But for your benefit, broadly speaking you've probably got a few different camps of people:
1) Sack Ridsdale, Lowe and the owners aren't the main problem
2) Sack Lowe, Ridsdale and the owners aren't the main problem
3) Sack Lowe and Ridsdale, the owners aren't the main problem
4) Nothing will change without new owners
5) Nothing is wrong

Most people are probably around 2, 3 or 4 at the moment. There are nuances of course like which owners we feel are accountable etc.

As time has gone on though sacking Lowe has got more popular because even with the parameters he works under, it's just clear that he's not cut out for managing at this level. The fact you mentioned you felt you'd be ok without him when he left in the league below is telling.

On that final point, I'd actually be curious if after you'd read around a bit if all of the criticisms we have are familiar, or if there's anything 'new' compared to when he was at Plymouth.
 
No, I'm being massively misquoted there. I'm saying everything else is bad enough without needing to use a less reliable metric in isolation. I stand by my point that xg in isolation doesn't mean much. The fact that 12 Prem teams are currently "outperforming" it supports my view (make it 10 if you take away a couple that are very close to it).
Xg is one metric to be used along with many others.

Why would that support your view? Natural variance means that some will overperform, some will underperform, and a relatively even split suggests that it's about right?
 
1000010580.png

Looks like Lowe's been on the BBC's football live blog... 🤣
 
No, I'm being massively misquoted there. I'm saying everything else is bad enough without needing to use a less reliable metric in isolation. I stand by my point that xg in isolation doesn't mean much. The fact that 12 Prem teams are currently "outperforming" it supports my view (make it 10 if you take away a couple that are very close to it).
Xg is one metric to be used along with many others.

Fair enough, it's just not 'less reliable' in my opinion (or the vast majority of people working in world football).

As for '12/10 teams are outperforming their XG' doesn't discount XG as a metric. It's just an indicator of how well you are doing Vs 'an average' if you will. It just suggests those teams may be having a good spell and should expect a drop in form over the next few months. Actual Vs XG often shows you when you are being flukey/enjoying a bit of luck (ours one of the highest for the vast majority of the season- again supports what we are seeing).

For me it just puts the nail in the coffin of any 'we are X points off the play offs' defence. Not that anyone seems to be even making those excuses now. XG supports what we've all seen all season. Flukey start followed by relegation form.
 
Welcome! Apologies if your earnest question feels like it's being dismissed but as others have indicated it's become quite a pattern with fans of other teams asking why we want Lowe gone. Although they often come with a lecture about how we shouldn't aspire to any better (a talking point that completely ignores the likes of Luton and Brentford from the past few years and Ipswich's successes from this season).

Just to bullet point the main talking points. Those who want Ryan gone want him gone for any of the following reasons:
- We have been playing poorly for a long time. This includes when we were top of the league (23rd for chance creation, only three clean sheets all season, meaning we can't attack or defend)
- His failure to play the attacking football he promised on his arrival (see chance creation data)
- The lack of improvement in anything he's promised (set pieces are no better, youth players don't get more game time etc)
- His inability to take responsibility (see soundbites about players not following the plan)
- His tactics (Norwich and Swansea were two leaky sides and we went to park the bus, our constant crosses against Sheffield Wednesday)
- Bizarre team selections (e.g. Swansea away)
- Bizarre substitutions (pretty much most games, especially how late they are)
- His recruitment despite being the most backed manager since our return to the Championship (Mads Frøkjaer Jensen barely plays despite the money we paid, Calvin Ramsay signed injured and doesn't make the squad when fit, still no proper wingbacks despite his main formation being 5-3-2/3-5-2)
- The appearance he has favourites (Robbie Brady, Ryan Ledson and Ben Woodburn keep getting minutes despite not being rated)
- The players getting contract extensions who don't add much value (Brady and Woodburn aren't rated, Cunningham is nearly always injured)
- His dismissal of fan opinions (openly implying Chelsea on Saturday doesn't matter and suggesting your opinions are irrelevant if you don't have coaching badges)
- Players seemingly not being fit
- There are unemployed managers who probably would improve us
- Players seemingly going backwards as footballers (Ali McCann, Mads Frøkjaer, Freddie Woodman, Ryan Ledson) and very few getting better (maybe Brad Potts)

We could talk about expectations, about if the squad is good enough for top six etc, the crux of the matter is nothing has improved in his time here. While that's not entirely his fault, there isn't much reason to keep him. I would genuinely like to hear the argument to keep him. In a perfect world he turns the form around and the club doesn't have to pay money to remove him and his backroom staff. However at present the argument to keep him is little more than the squad (that he's had a big role in assembling) isn't good enough but we shouldn't expect much better anyway.

I guess all I'm doing though is articulating a series of points you and your fellow Plymouth fans are already aware of. The fact you wouldn't want him back despite him managing a team that's higher in the table than you and has got them topping the league this season deep down highlights exactly why we want him gone. He simply isn't cut out to be a Championship manager.
Great summary!
 
If they’d put him on garden leave would we know yet?

If they don’t have the cash to pot him then why not do this and get Marsh to step up temporarily with a view to permanent appointment if he does well?

What a massive boost for players and fans to see the back of the useless twat Lowe and his comical ideas.

Done now to get the best for everyone in the big match v Chelsea.

I'm well up for Marsh taking over short term if we are skint.
 
I disagree, I think xg is extremely limited. Browne's header is a great chance because: he's virtually unchallenged, he is running onto the ball, and he's very good at hitting the target in those positions. Does xg take any of that into account? If not, I can't really see what it offers.

In short, yes it does account for at least most of that.

What people don't take in to consideration is that it is weighted against an ever changing list of information.

So, for example, xg data from 1 year ago will have been calculated against a lesser data set than xg today.

That adjusts how you read the data. If you're outperforming your xG you need to work out if it's luck, badly adjusted data, or are your players above the average standard?

In our case, at the start of the season, you'd argue was massive luck. Teams outperforming xG at the top of the Premiership, however, are likely to have better finishers than the average of your data set.
 
On that final point, I'd actually be curious if after you'd read around a bit if all of the criticisms we have are familiar, or if there's anything 'new' compared to when he was at Plymouth.


We always suspected Schumacher and Dewsnip were the brains behind the operation and this seems to have been proven.

During his final season with us in League 1 he would get in to arguments with fans after the game…..and there was a particularly remarkable incident when the fan he argued with was on the other side of the pitch…..it was like he made a point to seek him out after the game….

In our first season back we had a bunch of loan players who were poor players and absolute muppets in and around the dressing room. Schumacher and Dewsnip got rid of them and replaced them with players like Whittaker, Mumba and Azaz as we got 101 points.

I’ve often wondered if Lowe demanded they be brought in or whether the recruitment team got it completely wrong. I suspect it may have been a bit of both.
 
I thought yesterdays defeat might have been the end (it still might be) but a few chants of ‘we want Ryan Lowe’ out in the next home game/away game should spell the end.

Although the forum is pretty conclusive all I’ve heard so far is a few boos at matches. In the Chelsea game we should all chant ‘time to go time to go time to go.’ A few banners as wel - like when westley get sacked. Should make the owners notice then.
 
Had a decent run of 2 years to produce.

More than most get.

I backed him. The Club backed him.

Nov 28th when I posted these 6 little words "Cannot - and will not - defend that" was a major turning point for myself.
 
He had a go and it isn't working.

Time To Go with our Best Wishes.
Good to see you back @Jack Daniels. 👍👍
 
We always suspected Schumacher and Dewsnip were the brains behind the operation and this seems to have been proven.

During his final season with us in League 1 he would get in to arguments with fans after the game…..and there was a particularly remarkable incident when the fan he argued with was on the other side of the pitch…..it was like he made a point to seek him out after the game….

In our first season back we had a bunch of loan players who were poor players and absolute muppets in and around the dressing room. Schumacher and Dewsnip got rid of them and replaced them with players like Whittaker, Mumba and Azaz as we got 101 points.

I’ve often wondered if Lowe demanded they be brought in or whether the recruitment team got it completely wrong. I suspect it may have been a bit of both.

Did you folks also use "MRKT Insights" as your recruitment channel? And did Schumacher keep them or get rid when Lowe went?

I would say jury is still out on them here, although they have widened our net from UK and Ireland to Europe.
 
Back
Top