Skip to main content

Today

Today

Indeed I have. But there is also 'it is doing OK but it could be a bit better'. As it is I wouldn't change the starting line-upfrom the last couple of games unless forced to do so - something which it seems will be necessary this week-end and which will give us the opportunity to give us an extra bit of attacking width.


"a bit better"? 8 wins and 2 draws in the last 10? And here we have a thread saying what if we did this, or brought this player in, or maybe dropped this guy for that guy?

I don't know how many times I have read on here that "Grayson doesn't know his best team" or that "Grayson keeps changing the team/system" etc.

Now he has it as spot on as a manager is ever likely to achieve, some are asking for changes.

U-N-B-E-L-I-E-V-A-B-L-E.
 
Last edited:
"a bit better"? 8 wins and 2 draws in the last 10? And here we have a thread saying what if we did this, or brought this player in, or maybe dropped this guy for that guy?

I don't know how many times I have read on here that "Grayson doesn't know his best team" or that "Grayson keeps changing the team/system etc.

Now he has it as spot on as a manager is ever likely to achieve, some are asking for changes.

U-N-B-E-L-I-E-V-A-B-L-E.

Says the guy living 4,000 miles away who last watched a North End league match when?

IMO Clarke is better at CB than Wright and Wiseman is a better RB than Clarke. If Grayson was to swap it round I wouldn't be fussed but I'm also happy with things as they are now.
 
I think he's great as well, but at CB, not RB. I'm allowed that opinion, right?

I think you're right in that Clarke is better at CB than at RB. However Grayson is also right that Clarke is a better right back, all round defender and leader than Wiseman or Woods.

Wiseman has been responsible for so many goals conceded. He's fast and excellent going forward but inept defensively. He has poor awareness and positional sense. Clarke doesn't and is far superior in the air.

You also have to bear in mind Wiseman has had Humphrey in front of hIm who covers well defensively.

Presently the shape of the team is more attacking with Welsh screening a back 4 and Johnson, Robinson, Beckford, Garner, Gallagher forming a very attacking side.

CLarke is not being afforded the protection that the right back and left back was earlier in the season. Same goes for Laird really.

There is no way I would swap Wiseman in at the moment. We would fall apart at the back with laird, wiseman and hunts with Bailey wright. 3 strong competent defenders who all do well in the air at set pieces is invaluable. Clarke would be a big miss in there and Grayson knows it.
 
Last edited:
I think you're right in that Clarke is better at CB than at RB. However Grayson is also right that Clarke is a better right back, all round defender and leader than Wiseman or Woods.

Wiseman has been responsible for so many goals conceded. He's fast and excellent going forward but inept defensively. He has poor awareness and positional sense. Clarke doesn't and is far superior in the air.

You also have to bear in mind Wiseman has had Humphrey in front of hIm who covers well defensively.

Presently the shape of the team is more attacking with Welsh screening a back 4 and Johnson, Robinson, Beckford, Garner, Gallagher forming a very attacking side.

CLarke is not being afforded the protection that the right back and left back was earlier in the season. Same goes for Laird really.

Absolutely spot on.
 
Says the guy living 4,000 miles away who last watched a North End league match when?

IMO Clarke is better at CB than Wright and Wiseman is a better RB than Clarke. If Grayson was to swap it round I wouldn't be fussed but I'm also happy with things as they are now.


Hey Jimmy, why do I have to see games to state that a manager couldn't get much better than 8 wins and 2 draws out of 10 attempts?

Do you have a few screws loose?
 
I think you're right in that Clarke is better at CB than at RB. However Grayson is also right that Clarke is a better right back, all round defender and leader than Wiseman or Woods.

Wiseman has been responsible for so many goals conceded. He's fast and excellent going forward but inept defensively. He has poor awareness and positional sense. Clarke doesn't and is far superior in the air.

You also have to bear in mind Wiseman has had Humphrey in front of hIm who covers well defensively.

Presently the shape of the team is more attacking with Welsh screening a back 4 and Johnson, Robinson, Beckford, Garner, Gallagher forming a very attacking side.

CLarke is not being afforded the protection that the right back and left back was earlier in the season. Same goes for Laird really.

There is no way I would swap Wiseman in at the moment. We would fall apart at the back with laird, wiseman and hunts with Bailey wright. 3 strong competent defenders who all do well in the air at set pieces is invaluable. Clarke would be a big miss in there and Grayson knows it.

I see the point, but Bailey Wright was at fault for Barnsley's and lost his man a few other occasions. Clarke at CB then wiseman / woods at RB would just be as solid, with more intent going forward.
 
I see the point, but Bailey Wright was at fault for Barnsley's and lost his man a few other occasions. Clarke at CB then wiseman / woods at RB would just be as solid, with more intent going forward.

More intent on going forward???? How much more intent does a team need with Garner, Beckford, Gallagher, Robinson and Johnson. That is half a team! Not to mention Scott Laird getting forward, That just leaves Welsh to hold everything together when the opposition come forward.

So in your mind we would have no right back because he is too busy bombing forward and then our non existent right winger due to the formation we play to cover an empty space? Clarke gets exposed because we have no protection for him and yes he does lack pace to play there, but you watch how many times he intercepts the ball before it gets to the winger. He reads play ridiculously well, but at the same time cannot commit to everything because, again, he has no protection. Just for the record I rate Wiseman highly but not in our current formation.
 
With regard to Clarke at right back I think that at least a small part of it is to do with defending corners. Apart from the centre backs we don't have a great deal of height in the side and without Davies playing its more of an issue defending the set piece. As we know, whilst a better player in general at right back Wiseman is a fanny when it comes to challenging for headers.

A lot of goals are scored from set plays. We don't need Wiseman's better ability with the ball at feet at the current stage. Clarke is very handy to have in both boxes. It kind of makes sense.
 
Defensively, Clarke is sound at right back, it's just his distribution which is a bit dodgy. We couldn't play this current system with Wiseman as he needs a winger in front of him who can cover.

Our current formation is weird really, but good.

It's pretty much 2 centrebacks with the right back tucked in,
Laird a bit more advanced,
Welsh on his own in defensive midfield,
Gallagher and Johnson in pretty much free roles,
Robinson wide left, no-one on the right,
Beckford as an out and out striker and Garner playing right across the front line.

Must be a ball ache to line-up against.
 
Seems Clarke himself prefers to play at centre half then.

http://www.lep.co.uk/sport/national-football/clarke-glad-to-be-back-in-the-middle-1-7194046

Preston North End captain Tom Clarke was happy to be back in his favoured position as North End beat Rochdale 1-0 at Deepdale.

In recent weeks defender Clarke has been playing on the right but after centre half Paul Huntington hurt his back in North End’s 1-1 draw with Fleetwood last Sunday Clarke slotted back into the middle.

Clarke rekindled his partnership with Bailey Wright against Dale and was pleased to mark his 100th PNE appearance with a clean sheet.

He said: "It was nice to get back in the middle. I’m comfortable in either position but I sort of prefer centre half."

"It is somewhere that I have probably played most for my other clubs and it was nice to get back in there"
 
Our current formation is weird really, but good.

It's pretty much 2 centrebacks with the right back tucked in,
Laird a bit more advanced,
Welsh on his own in defensive midfield,
Gallagher and Johnson in pretty much free roles,
Robinson wide left, no-one on the right,
Beckford as an out and out striker and Garner playing right across the front line.

Must be a ball ache to line-up against.

Agreed - what I have tried to point out is that it could do with one less left-sided player and one more right-sided player to balance it out a bit more. A right-footed version of Johnson would be good.
 
Back
Top