I can see the logic a in purchasing Doyle and with our financial constraints you could say it was a risk worth taking.
Doyle was the second highest scorer in league 1 behind Garner and he only played half a season before his move to Cardiff where I think he scored 7 in 15 games before he fell out of favour. Regardless of what he did when he was on loan to us getting League 1's second highest goal scorer for about 200k is bloody good business when you consider Bradshaw went for 800k and Omar Bogle at Grimsby is getting shopped around at 1 million plus. If we had signed Doyle when he was at Chesterfield (of which there was no chance) I bet most of PNE Online would have been creaming themselves, me included.
When he played for us last season he scored roughly the same amount as Garner without any penalties and being in and out of the team, I think SG thought he could get more out of Doyle like he has done with Beckford, Hugil, Garner and Makienok whilst he has been here and like I've said for 200k it's a risk well worth taking. The 3 year contract does baffle me a bit but I think that Doyle would have just sat at Cardiff if anything less than 3 years was offered to him.
200k if it doesn't work it's a minuscule amount to write off, if it works you look like a genius and the fans build a golden statue to you outside Deepdale, for SG I think it was a calculated risk well worth taking. It also puts us in a strong position when it comes to negotiating new signings as we didn't know whether Makienok and Hugil were going to cut it this season and whether Beckford was going to stay injury free, if those things don't happen then every team starts slapping more than the 200k we paid for Doyle on top of transfer fees and loan fees.
I wouldn't be too bothered if he was to depart to a League 1 club, the gamble won't have worked, but I feel these are the gambles we should be taking to progress us, we've taken them with Cunningham, Clarke, Beckford, Gallagher and Robinson as examples and they are paying off.