Skip to main content

Eoin doyle

Eoin doyle

I think if Doyle was played up front in the middle and given a run of games in that role the same chance hughill has been given he would score the goals.

What's been missed in the game he and beckford were sent of in at sheff Wednesday was the goal he scored to get us back in that game, his finish was very clinical and gave a peek of what he can do in the proper centre forward role.

He might - but only feeding off a strike partner. In a 'lone' striker role, which is what Hugill is often asked to play, I think he would be too lightweight.

Finally, some bloody football nous.
 
He might - but only feeding off a strike partner. In a 'lone' striker role, which is what Hugill is often asked to play, I think he would be too lightweight.

I know what you're saying and agree he'd probably thrive alongside someone like Makienok to feed off the knock downs. Although it depends how we play doesn't it really?

We have the pace and skill in the squad now to exploit the space on the wings and whip in plenty of dangerous low crosses as well as lots of creative talent in centre midfield capable of playing defence-splitting passes. If our strategy concentrated on those types of attacks rather than the long high hopeful punts upfield to the big man then I see every reason why he should be given the chance to be our lone striker.

He has a lot of talent which I don't believe we've yet made the most of.
 
I know what you're saying and agree he'd probably thrive alongside someone like Makienok to feed off the knock downs. Although it depends how we play doesn't it really?

In a flat 4.4.2 then Doyle might prosper upfront with any of Makienok, Hugill, even Beckford. Same in a 3.5.2. But when we play that 4.3.3 with, say, McGeady and Robinson wide of a single central striker then, as I said, I doubt Doyle would be much of a threat though I might be wrong. But swap one of those wide players for another striker and the formation might work - it would just mean that the fullback on that flank would have to get up on the overlap but Vermilj, Baptiste and Cunningham all see pretty good at that.
 
Probably the best we can ask for in the short term, long term I hope we sign someone more clinical.

Fair point Ron.

I just can't understand the logic behind the purchase of Doyle. It's not as though he set the world alight during his time at Cardiff. Poor buy IMHO and nothing I've seen from him makes me believe he has the qualities of a Championship centre forward.

If a League 1 club comes in for him then I'd get rid. He may end up as part of a deal for Wyke. Who knows?
 
I think doyle reminds me of beavon a bit, would always make chances and seem like he was going to come good but now i'm not so sure.
 
Fair point Ron.

I just can't understand the logic behind the purchase of Doyle. It's not as though he set the world alight during his time at Cardiff. Poor buy IMHO and nothing I've seen from him makes me believe he has the qualities of a Championship centre forward.

If a League 1 club comes in for him then I'd get rid. He may end up as part of a deal for Wyke. Who knows?

I can see the logic a in purchasing Doyle and with our financial constraints you could say it was a risk worth taking.

Doyle was the second highest scorer in league 1 behind Garner and he only played half a season before his move to Cardiff where I think he scored 7 in 15 games before he fell out of favour. Regardless of what he did when he was on loan to us getting League 1's second highest goal scorer for about 200k is bloody good business when you consider Bradshaw went for 800k and Omar Bogle at Grimsby is getting shopped around at 1 million plus. If we had signed Doyle when he was at Chesterfield (of which there was no chance) I bet most of PNE Online would have been creaming themselves, me included.

When he played for us last season he scored roughly the same amount as Garner without any penalties and being in and out of the team, I think SG thought he could get more out of Doyle like he has done with Beckford, Hugil, Garner and Makienok whilst he has been here and like I've said for 200k it's a risk well worth taking. The 3 year contract does baffle me a bit but I think that Doyle would have just sat at Cardiff if anything less than 3 years was offered to him.

200k if it doesn't work it's a minuscule amount to write off, if it works you look like a genius and the fans build a golden statue to you outside Deepdale, for SG I think it was a calculated risk well worth taking. It also puts us in a strong position when it comes to negotiating new signings as we didn't know whether Makienok and Hugil were going to cut it this season and whether Beckford was going to stay injury free, if those things don't happen then every team starts slapping more than the 200k we paid for Doyle on top of transfer fees and loan fees.

I wouldn't be too bothered if he was to depart to a League 1 club, the gamble won't have worked, but I feel these are the gambles we should be taking to progress us, we've taken them with Cunningham, Clarke, Beckford, Gallagher and Robinson as examples and they are paying off.
 
Last edited:
Fair point Ron.

I just can't understand the logic behind the purchase of Doyle. It's not as though he set the world alight during his time at Cardiff. Poor buy IMHO and nothing I've seen from him makes me believe he has the qualities of a Championship centre forward.

If a League 1 club comes in for him then I'd get rid. He may end up as part of a deal for Wyke. Who knows?

Carlisle couldn't afford his wages, so if it was a loan move I wouldn't want to be paying a big chunk otherwise we may as well keep him.

I dont think we'll be actively looking to move him on but if someone comes in for him then there may be movement.

A 3 year deal was baffling, but Ron has summed it up for me in that it was a gamble probably worth going for.
 
I can see the logic a in purchasing Doyle and with our financial constraints you could say it was a risk worth taking.

Doyle was the second highest scorer in league 1 behind Garner and he only played half a season before his move to Cardiff where I think he scored 7 in 15 games before he fell out of favour. Regardless of what he did when he was on loan to us getting League 1's second highest goal scorer for about 200k is bloody good business when you consider Bradshaw went for 800k and Omar Bogle at Grimsby is getting shopped around at 1 million plus. If we had signed Doyle when he was at Chesterfield (of which there was no chance) I bet most of PNE Online would have been creaming themselves, me included.

When he played for us last season he scored roughly the same amount as Garner without any penalties and being in and out of the team, I think SG thought he could get more out of Doyle like he has done with Beckford, Hugil, Garner and Makienok whilst he has been here and like I've said for 200k it's a risk well worth taking. The 3 year contract does baffle me a bit but I think that Doyle would have just sat at Cardiff if anything less than 3 years was offered to him.

200k if it doesn't work it's a minuscule amount to write off, if it works you look like a genius and the fans build a golden statue to you outside Deepdale, for SG I think it was a calculated risk well worth taking. It also puts us in a strong position when it comes to negotiating new signings as we didn't know whether Makienok and Hugil were going to cut it this season and whether Beckford was going to stay injury free, if those things don't happen then every team starts slapping more than the 200k we paid for Doyle on top of transfer fees and loan fees.

I wouldn't be too bothered if he was to depart to a League 1 club, the gamble won't have worked, but I feel these are the gambles we should be taking to progress us, we've taken them with Cunningham, Clarke, Beckford, Gallagher and Robinson as examples and they are paying off.

Doyle scored 5 in 16 at Cardiff, 2 were penalties in the same game. So if not for the game he scored 2 penalties he scored 3 in 15 other games. He did little at Cardiff, he did little for us on loan. He's not been a regular goalscorer for 2 years now. Personally I don't think paying any fee for him is good business at our level. I'd rather have spent 450k extra on Tom Bradshaw (650k fee), who would be on a less wage then Doyle. And Bradshaw is 4 years younger so time on his side to improve more.
 
I can see the logic a in purchasing Doyle and with our financial constraints you could say it was a risk worth taking.

Doyle was the second highest scorer in league 1 behind Garner and he only played half a season before his move to Cardiff where I think he scored 7 in 15 games before he fell out of favour. Regardless of what he did when he was on loan to us getting League 1's second highest goal scorer for about 200k is bloody good business when you consider Bradshaw went for 800k and Omar Bogle at Grimsby is getting shopped around at 1 million plus. If we had signed Doyle when he was at Chesterfield (of which there was no chance) I bet most of PNE Online would have been creaming themselves, me included.

When he played for us last season he scored roughly the same amount as Garner without any penalties and being in and out of the team, I think SG thought he could get more out of Doyle like he has done with Beckford, Hugil, Garner and Makienok whilst he has been here and like I've said for 200k it's a risk well worth taking. The 3 year contract does baffle me a bit but I think that Doyle would have just sat at Cardiff if anything less than 3 years was offered to him.

200k if it doesn't work it's a minuscule amount to write off, if it works you look like a genius and the fans build a golden statue to you outside Deepdale, for SG I think it was a calculated risk well worth taking. It also puts us in a strong position when it comes to negotiating new signings as we didn't know whether Makienok and Hugil were going to cut it this season and whether Beckford was going to stay injury free, if those things don't happen then every team starts slapping more than the 200k we paid for Doyle on top of transfer fees and loan fees.

I wouldn't be too bothered if he was to depart to a League 1 club, the gamble won't have worked, but I feel these are the gambles we should be taking to progress us, we've taken them with Cunningham, Clarke, Beckford, Gallagher and Robinson as examples and they are paying off.

A very thought provoking post and very true Ron.
 
Doyle would certainly have converted several of the chances missed by Hugill

Not sure I agree. Hugill's poor but at least he gets into the positions. Doyle usually just isn't there, and we've seen him fluff his lines quite a few times in front of goal just like Hugill.
 
Not sure I agree. Hugill's poor but at least he gets into the positions. Doyle usually just isn't there, and we've seen him fluff his lines quite a few times in front of goal just like Hugill.

Apart from the unforgettable miss vs Brentford, how many sitter has Doyle actually missed?
 
Apart from the unforgettable miss vs Brentford, how many sitter has Doyle actually missed?

Barnsley at home this season he missed a free header about 8 yards out. They subsequently went and won the game with a clinical finish. I also recall him missing 2 one on ones at Peterborough in the cup last season.

He's missed his fair share of chances too, and I don't understand where this myth about him being a great finisher/the best finisher at the club comes from from some supporters. The only prolific spell of his career came in half a season in L1, and it's been nearly 2 years since then. How long do we persist? If we have top 6 aspirations we can't wait forever for the same average strikers to start producing.

As Staffordwhite says earlier in the thread, it is funny how players suddenly become better in the fans eyes after a long spell on the bench. He's been on the bench because he consistently puts in underwhelming performances when he plays, with very few goals.

Hope he comes good, doubt he will (I don't even think he'll get a run of games). Would be a decent signing for a top 6 L1 club.
 
Doyle scored 5 in 16 at Cardiff, 2 were penalties in the same game. So if not for the game he scored 2 penalties he scored 3 in 15 other games. He did little at Cardiff, he did little for us on loan. He's not been a regular goalscorer for 2 years now. Personally I don't think paying any fee for him is good business at our level. I'd rather have spent 450k extra on Tom Bradshaw (650k fee), who would be on a less wage then Doyle. And Bradshaw is 4 years younger so time on his side to improve more.

He's not been a regular starter like he was at Chesterfield for 2 years now, being in and out of a team and shipped out on loan can do a lot to a players confidence that was probably Graysons thinking when he decided to sign him.

I wouldn't have spent the extra on Bradshaw even if he was 4 years younger because I don't see him as having the traits to be a regular goal scorer in this division, for me he would be a younger and more expensive buy as Doyle is.

Our level in the Championship is still dictated by our finances and club attractiveness when it comes to transfers, once our income hopefully starts to increase or TH releases the purse strings a little bit and we are firmly seen as an established hopefully play off challenging side then signings like Doyle and Bradshaw will not be our level.
 
Doyle would certainly have converted several of the chances missed by Hugill

Doyle missed loads of sitters when he played last season, some absolutely shocking ones, don't know where this myth has come from that he's a better finisher than any of our other players.

Makienok and Hugill would both bag 20+ in League One if they played in a team that creates plenty of chances.
 
Back
Top