Honestly some of the comments on this thread are a disgrace. Yes Garner's final season for us was hardly superb but he was playing in a very defensive setup. Have people forgotten the fact that he scored 53 goals for us in the two seasons prior? Also perhaps one of the greatest goals deepdale has ever seen? Not to mention the fact that he was an absolute pain in the arse every single week because he left everything out on the pitch. If McGeady returned and also I'd definitely have Garner over Doyle, Makienok and Beckford. Grayson could definetly get double figures out of Garner with the team that finished last season. Sure he had his shortcomings last year but let's not forget that at times he won us games on his own during a time that we needed it the most e.g Fleetwood, Port Vale, Swindon and the four goals at home to Crewe. Goalscorers don't just forget how to score. On a cut price deal with some good service I would definetly take him back. Probably do Hugill some good to have some decent competition.