Skip to main content

Garner to return?

Garner to return?

A punt on the lad Cummings (Hibs) or Watkins (Exeter) please.

Yes, I know they will cost (by our standards) around the £1.5m - £2m mark which in todays Championship is very very low for a striker. They also have age / sell on value on their collective sides.
 
Garner was great for us, but we need to move on. Re-signing him would not only take a large chunk out of our transfer budget, but also I fear it would encourage us to resort to pumping long balls in Garners general direction, as we did when he was here, rather than play the good football on the deck we've seen this season which has been both better to watch and far more effective.

That is not a pop at Garner, merely an observation that due to his salmon-like jumping ability and workman like performances we resorted all to quickly to hopeful punts in the general direction of Garner in 2015/16.
 
giphy.gif
 
There are quite a few fans on the pnefc twitter hashtag calling for his return. A classic case of that saying which goes something like you're never more valuable when you're not in the team, or in this case not at the club anymore.

The service wasn't amazing for him in the Championship with us, but he still had chances which he missed, and his record at other Championship clubs is not good either.

In hindsight it was the correct decision to sell. I felt things were going a little bit stale for him at PNE with him struggling to adapt to the level.

I'd rather we looked forward and discussed searching for 'the new Nugent', or 'the new Garner', rather than constantly pining for the old ones to return, especially in Garner's case because he's never done much above League 1.
 
To be fair, if this were to happen then it's the equivalent of Rangers paying us £1m to take garner on a season long loan. Which at the start of last season would have seemed like a good deal
 
Honestly some of the comments on this thread are a disgrace. Yes Garner's final season for us was hardly superb but he was playing in a very defensive setup. Have people forgotten the fact that he scored 53 goals for us in the two seasons prior? Also perhaps one of the greatest goals deepdale has ever seen? Not to mention the fact that he was an absolute pain in the arse every single week because he left everything out on the pitch. If McGeady returned and also I'd definitely have Garner over Doyle, Makienok and Beckford. Grayson could definetly get double figures out of Garner with the team that finished last season. Sure he had his shortcomings last year but let's not forget that at times he won us games on his own during a time that we needed it the most e.g Fleetwood, Port Vale, Swindon and the four goals at home to Crewe. Goalscorers don't just forget how to score. On a cut price deal with some good service I would definetly take him back. Probably do Hugill some good to have some decent competition.
 
Honestly some of the comments on this thread are a disgrace. Yes Garner's final season for us was hardly superb but he was playing in a very defensive setup. Have people forgotten the fact that he scored 53 goals for us in the two seasons prior? Also perhaps one of the greatest goals deepdale has ever seen? Not to mention the fact that he was an absolute pain in the arse every single week because he left everything out on the pitch. If McGeady returned and also I'd definitely have Garner over Doyle, Makienok and Beckford. Grayson could definetly get double figures out of Garner with the team that finished last season. Sure he had his shortcomings last year but let's not forget that at times he won us games on his own during a time that we needed it the most e.g Fleetwood, Port Vale, Swindon and the four goals at home to Crewe. Goalscorers don't just forget how to score. On a cut price deal with some good service I would definetly take him back. Probably do Hugill some good to have some decent competition.
Well said
 
Back
Top