This.I’d agree with all that apart from the last bit...I would say Peter is controlled from the Isle of Man.
Harrop
He also has no pace at all, so it's not like we could see him leading a counter attack like DJ at Bournemouth in mid-week.Clearly got some level of ability with his United upbringing etc, but he can't tackle, struggles to track runners as a midfielder, finds it difficult to beat a man out wide and it's still not clear where his best position is in his fourth season here.
I'm just not sure what it is Harrop offers that's tangible, other than the odd set piece and long range strike. As you say, off the ball he offers nothing, can't beat a man/no pace. He doesn't set up goals either despite his tag as a creative player.
I don't think there's many attributes there to make him a success at this level, yet we're constantly told that he has so much "ability".
Imho he is in danger of becoming another James Wilson and dropping into the lower leagues, unless he gets his act together. I want him to succeed as much as the next man but I am pretty fed up of seeing him given chances and doing a disappearing act.
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2015
- Messages
- 7,883
What good things did Fisher do yesterday?
Oh yes, that’s right he wasn’t available, he was banned for being a complete & utter moron, letting his team & club down. Fisher is an absolute liability.
Much rather have a quality player who misses games due to suspension than a guy who is always available and misses games through lack of ability
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2015
- Messages
- 7,883
He was one of many poor performers today.
But there, in a nutshell, is the whole problem. He couldn’t have had a better opportunity than yesterday. Open midfield, playing in his ‘natural position’ in the 10 against a side in the bottom 3 and he couldn’t even get on the ball. Chance to take a game by the scruff of the neck and prove the doubters wrong and he produces that.
Everyone saying that losing Pearson killed us, and it certainly didn’t help, but Harrop has to do more in the creative role. So much more.
Timely reminder to all that he will be 25 in 9 days and we still discuss him like a 20 year old prospect with potential. If you haven’t got it at 25, you aren’t getting it. End of.
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2009
- Messages
- 11,331
Much rather have a quality player who misses games due to suspension than a guy who is always available and misses games through lack of ability
He misses games cos of lack of ability in your opinion?
I had high hopes for Harrop and honestly felt that after his first "settling-in" season he would kick on. The injury came at a bad time for him but he should have used last season to really step up.
I've said it a few times he has talent but doesn't do enough to impact games and is very much a luxury player and we can't afford to carry people.
Will probably have an ok career at a mid-table Championship club but he is a long way short of doing it any higher.
I've seen very little progression from him over the last 3 years to suggest otherwise
I've said it a few times he has talent but doesn't do enough to impact games and is very much a luxury player and we can't afford to carry people.
Will probably have an ok career at a mid-table Championship club but he is a long way short of doing it any higher.
I've seen very little progression from him over the last 3 years to suggest otherwise
Modern day Joel Byrom?I think he is shit. He reminds me of the Wesley years when we signed a load of L2 guys who clearly couldn't have an impact as they weren't good enough.
'He's got to take the game by the scruff of the neck' - Neil's Harrop challenge
Preston North End drew 2-2 with Wycombe Wanderers in the Championship on Saturday
Pretty much what most of his critics have been saying about him for the last couple of years![]()
'He's got to take the game by the scruff of the neck' - Neil's Harrop challenge
Preston North End drew 2-2 with Wycombe Wanderers in the Championship on Saturdayt.co
Pretty much what most of his critics have been saying about him for the last couple of years
As Cloughie said ' Floats like a butterfly and stings like one'.
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2019
- Messages
- 178
Josh Harrop has never had a decent run in the team and when he has played a really good game AN drops him ,so there for he has lost all belief in his natural abilities An has never given him a proper run to let him settle after playing some good games gets dropped every time .How would you feel ?? We need a new manager thats the problem he is draining any confidence out of the players needs .something not right AN has to change or go .
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2004
- Messages
- 28,496
Lost all belief? Come on. He should be gagging for an opportunity like that, and despite his talents he didn't take advantage of it. If he's that mentally frail, maybe this isn't the career for him.
I'd have risked bringing Storey on to play right back when Pearo went off rather than have the Keepy-uppy Kid replace Johnson in the 10.
With Browne in the holding role I'd have had him jumping in front of Akinfenwe for their long balls out from the back.
With Browne in the holding role I'd have had him jumping in front of Akinfenwe for their long balls out from the back.
He hadn't got on the pitch for about 7 games. What do you expect? He won't be anywhere near match fit if he never gets a run. Personally I think he's being ruined here in a rigid system (especially at home), and he'll go on to have a good career somewhere.
I agree, but while AN is Manager he needs to harness his undoubted ability and work harder and extra if needed to find out just what he needs or is lacking, to add to his undoubted talentTo say he’s not good enough is nonsense IMO.
Ability wise he’s more than good enough, it’s what he does or is told to do with that ability that’s not good enough.
He hadn't got on the pitch for about 7 games. What do you expect? He won't be anywhere near match fit if he never gets a run. Personally I think he's being ruined here in a rigid system (especially at home), and he'll go on to have a good career somewhere.
Match fitness isn't an issue; not having his game head on is an issue ten minutes after getting into the game.
Where do you seeing him having a good career?
Last edited:
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2004
- Messages
- 912
His set pieces made me think he was improving and had been better than Gallys for a while.
My main concern was how he was brushed off the ball when trying to track back or going into the box.
Reminded me of Callum Robinson early in his career with us and I thought he would bulk up a bit and progress, but he seems to have stood still and flits in and out of games ( not helped by just having the odd game here and there).
I think he needs to do a Brownhill, control it pass to a man (no fancy flicks) and move into space.
There is a player there, but I thought that with Simon Whaley.
My main concern was how he was brushed off the ball when trying to track back or going into the box.
Reminded me of Callum Robinson early in his career with us and I thought he would bulk up a bit and progress, but he seems to have stood still and flits in and out of games ( not helped by just having the odd game here and there).
I think he needs to do a Brownhill, control it pass to a man (no fancy flicks) and move into space.
There is a player there, but I thought that with Simon Whaley.
Yep agree with this, he still can make a Player but he's at make or break and a few nuckle down (Macken, Basham. Ellis and more recently Ledson) after criticism, see the light and come through and many like Simon fall away.His set pieces made me think he was improving and had been better than Gallys for a while.
My main concern was how he was brushed off the ball when trying to track back or going into the box.
Reminded me of Callum Robinson early in his career with us and I thought he would bulk up a bit and progress, but he seems to have stood still and flits in and out of games ( not helped by just having the odd game here and there).
I think he needs to do a Brownhill, control it pass to a man (no fancy flicks) and move into space.
There is a player there, but I thought that with Simon Whaley.
He really really needs to work to his strengths but also work on minimising his weaknesses, otherwise he will be another Player who SHOULD have had a decent career that people remember in the future - rather than just another wasted talent.
If you honestly don't think match fitness is an issue when he has barely featured all season, we can't have a serious conversation about him. You can't expect players to come in from the cold out of nowhere and suddenly turn it on. Hunts is the only player I can think of who manages that.Match fitness isn't an issue; not having his game head on is an issue ten minutes after getting into the game.
Where do you seeing him having a good career?
Look at Ledson - no one was really sure about him until he got a run of games and now he's virtually undroppabble.
I think Harrop doesn't suit Neil's system - in a nutshell. He cannot play the way Neil wants him too. I don't think he is a bad player - he just doesn't fit the system - I am surprised he has an extension. Thought he would have been sold on to another club in the summer to be fair.