Skip to main content

Joe Garner

Joe Garner

I dont think there is too much wrong with people saying Garner can't hack it at this level. His supporters point to just about everything else he does 'for the team', but most of us know a bit about the game to be fair, and I remember my PNE hero in the 70s was Alex Bruce, yet I would not have thought for one minute Alex would have been top flight standard, which would have been upsetting, but sadly, true. I think it might just be the same with Garner at this level too. I hope he proves us wrong, and I am not getting on his back and he is my favourite PNE player, but I am just being realistic and not putting rose tinted specs on over him. Basically, he will only silence his doubters by starting to score goals.
 
And they'll carry on doing so as long as referees allow them to do so. In the second half their time wasting was something Billy Davies would have been proud of and the referee must have told them to hurry up half a dozen times and gestured at his watch the same number of times to indicate he was adding the time on. He booked nobody and added no time on for time wasting - 4 minutes was the bare minimum for the goals, substitutions and bookings.

As for Garner's 'red card' incident, he was fouled, turned round (aggressively admittedly) but was then pushed into their player. The fact the referee, his assistant and the 4th official were all in close proximity and conferred at length with none of them thinking it was a red card implies that to be the case. We don't get to see the official reason for cautions but aggressive intent (for want of a better term) is a yellow card offence.

Having said all that, the content was with the Brentford player's body below the neck so not a red card in any case
The four minutes added were not sufficient even for the goals, subs and injuries let alone any time wasting. The incident where garner was fouled, the centre half booked and a Brentford player required treatment must have taken two minutes alone. Players know the time won't be added, why ref's bother pointing to their watches is beyond me.
 
Ok so you focus on that and completely ignore the rest of the statistics.

I exaggerated with the regularly sent off comment, but he was mistakenly identified last season at Port Vale when he chinned one of their players but the. Ref sent off someone else by mistake.

I've no agenda, just fed up with Garners antics and don't believe they help our cause.

My point is that you undermine your own arguments by making up spurious facts.
 
It is worth noting that Garner and Beckford had formed a tremendous partnership albeit in League one. It has been clear since day one that we had set up with playing them too and I firmly believe that had Beckford been available both he and Garner will have scored plenty more goals.

Brentford came out with a game plan (like many in league one did) to wind Garner up and try and get him sent off. When he isn't scoring we see a side of him maybe we don't like, however to talk about dropping him is farcical.

He has had to play up top on his own, play with May, Keane, Doyle, Hugill, chopping and changing every few weeks. I don't think we can really judge Garner at this level until he gets to play alongside someone who can cut it at this level. In the last few games he has put chances on a plate for Doyle who has made a hash of it.

Joe loves this club and yes maybe some folk have rose tinted specs on but without him at the moment we would literally have no threat in the final third what so ever. Is he undropable? Not at all, but in our current squad he can't be dropped.
 
Last edited:
28 appearances, 3 goals, 4 assists, 60 fouls, 9 yellow cards, 1 red card. What a fantastic contribution. Unfortunately it's the best we've got right now and that says everything.

This time last season i wasn't sure about promotion. Now here we are comfortable in midtable improving all the time.
Tugg you never mentioned how many time he has hit the post ,bar disallowed goals and penalty appeals turned down this season and there has been quite a few.
Joe has not had much luck and you always need that as a strike.
 
This time last season i wasn't sure about promotion. Now here we are comfortable in midtable improving all the time.
Tugg you never mentioned how many time he has hit the post ,bar disallowed goals and penalty appeals turned down this season and there has been quite a few.
Joe has not had much luck and you always need that as a strike.

Fair comment about luck. But those stats do serve to highlight a certain side of his game. I was surprised the number of fouls was so high, more than double the number of appearances. Not suggesting he should lose his 'edge' in that sense and neither have I said anywhere that he should be dropped, just think he should focus more on playing the game/ball rather than playing the opposition players.
 
This time last season i wasn't sure about promotion. Now here we are comfortable in midtable improving all the time.
Tugg you never mentioned how many time he has hit the post ,bar disallowed goals and penalty appeals turned down this season and there has been quite a few.
Joe has not had much luck and you always need that as a strike.

Or the amount of sitters he's missed , or the amount of times he's dived .
 
i dont get people like you, Garner is the best we have, always puts in a shift and never lets anybody down, and yet you pick on him to have a go at, it makes no sense to me !!!

I don't get people who would drag there balls through a mile of broken glass to defend garner . Yes he was class last season , has he been good enough this season ? I don't think so , just my opinion of course . SHOCKING
 
I don't get people who would drag there balls through a mile of broken glass to defend garner . Yes he was class last season , has he been good enough this season ? I don't think so , just my opinion of course . SHOCKING

Who would you be/have been playing instead of him?
 
I don't get people who would drag there balls through a mile of broken glass to defend garner . Yes he was class last season , has he been good enough this season ? I don't think so , just my opinion of course . SHOCKING

By your own admission , he was class last season, added to that, he is the best we have, the most likely one to grab us some goals and he works his bollocks off. why single him out. Every game i have seen this season there has been plenty of candidates for worst performance of the day and its never been Garner so again i ask , why pick on him !!!
 
I don't get people who would drag there balls through a mile of broken glass to defend garner . Yes he was class last season , has he been good enough this season ? I don't think so , just my opinion of course . SHOCKING

He won 18 areal battles against Middlesbrough . I think that's the most of any championship player. Had plenty of shots... He just isn't in form at the moment . Winning areal battles and shooting just not scoring . He will get there. If One of his shots had gone in today this thread wouldn't have been started ! Get a grip !

Hmm... flipperty flop.
 
I think we need a new target man to help the likes of Garner and Doyle out, and get the best out of them. Several of Garners goals last year were assisted by Kevin Davies, and I think we need a younger more mobile but still experienced battering ram of a forward to create the knock-downs for Garner/Doyle to finish. Hugill is too raw and too young for the role yet but the team needs that option.
 
The role Grayson has given Joey is adding to the lack of goals. He's playing as a target man.
He runs himself into the ground for PNE anyone who says drop him is clueless.
 
Back
Top